Daily Tribune closed down

The Daily Tribune newspaper was raided and shut down today. Identified as having a pro-Estrada editorial position, the government was clearly after making sure it didn’t come out with a devastating issue on Friday’s events.

I share in this statement from Newsbreak:

Press Statement

Twenty years ago, we regained our freedom of the press. Today, we
stand the risk of losing it.

It is ironic that on the day we celebrate people power, a glorious
and festive moment in our history, we are reminded that our freedoms are
fragile. They can easily be taken away.

We view the raid on Tribune, an opposition newspaper, with alarm.
It appears to signal the start of a crackdown on media organizations.

We have always believed that repression is never the answer to a
critical press. We remind the authorities that a free press is a
cornerstone of a democracy. Without it, we cannot claim to be a
democratic country.

Marites Danguilan Vitug
Editor in Chief
Newsbreak Magazine
Tel 687-5523/25
E-mail: [email protected]
Cell phone 0918-9126615

And so, the crackdown continues.

I seriously propose that the BLAWggers start preparing a common position for bloggers who find themselves shut down for content found offensive by the government. I will give an example of the kind of harassment to expect: one I.T. professional has been falsely rumored to be behind fugitive Nick Faeldon’s website. That government people spread the rumor,despite it’s not being true, suggests they’re out to damage the reputations of those they can, even if they don’t go after them legally. The experience of the PCIJ when it had an entry affected by a court ruling, also comes back to mind. Colleagues believe that for lack of an appropriate law, the internet, as far as free speech or content offensive to the government is concerned, can’t be touched. But the existence or lack of it, of a law, is no guarantee of protection.

For those who wonder why I’m so intransigent (besides my obvious interest as a writer), do read a column I wrote soon after my father’s death in 1998:

Dwindling fears

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

Manuel L. Quezon III.

44 thoughts on “Daily Tribune closed down

  1. I’m not an IT but I just hope there are back up servers and alternate access for pinoy bloggers as it may come to that. A mirror site may do(?). Keep the faith.

  2. I read “dwindling fears”….

    I always wanted to know more about you MLQ3 and that article was more than enough help.

    As the first blog site I ever visited and commented on, I have learned a lot and still continue to learn …

    Thanks for welcoming us!
    Do Blog on!

  3. I hope the writers of Tribune find other ways of communicating maybe thru the internet? Would another newspaper come to their aid and say you can write your views here?

  4. Madness is setting in; that’s what we should worry about. Stop this landslide, nah, that’s imposibble. Either she flees or be buried. She will turn to Martial Law without declaring it but it would just be a patch up job on a dam about to give way.

  5. scary. anything they don’t like is deemed seditous. PGMA is using the “state of emergency” declaration to pacify people

  6. we must fight, and we will fight. the great thing with the internet is that you cannot filter completely. even china cannot do it. but we must not only fight in cyberspace. we must also do it in the streets. the press must not be contained. the lawyers will surely do their thing and battle in the courts. we must remember that the strength of this nation is best manifested in crisis times.

  7. alarming ! we’re more than willing to help journalists, freedom fighters and revolutionists have their own relatively untraceable website to avoid censorship & prosecution.

  8. MLQ3,

    This is a very sad day – the closing down of The Tribune.

    There is no honor in gagging and intimidating people because they happen to oppose Gloria’s views.

  9. MLQ3,

    And which broadsheet will be next? Malaya? And which journalists and opinion writers will be arrested without a warrant? Ellen Tordesillas, Lito Banayo, Ducky Paredes? or our very own MLQ3?

    Many European editors, journalists and cartoonists have faced serious threats and intimidation to their liberty and life but no government has closed down a newspaper because its views opposed those of a particular government’s.

    We believe in the freedom of the press, in the people’s freedom of speech and in the overall freedom of expression.

  10. I heard today that the printers of Malaya experienced a visit from the police, but the cops said they were “just looking.”

  11. MLQ3,

    It will be interesting to read Max Soliven’s reaction in his column tomorrow on Gloria’s clamping down on the rights of a fellow columnist, Ninez Cacho, to air her views.

    He who has never forgiven Marcos for the dictator’s slight to his freedom of speech until he was liberated by Cory Aquino surely will come to Cacho’s defence.

  12. MLQ3,

    For info:

    BGen Danilo Lim was a member of PMA Class ‘77 but graduated from West Point in 1978.

    Lim, who was then a Philippine Army major, was also the leader of the military group that stormed Atrium in Makati during the 1989 coup d’etat against Cory Aquino.

    Lim is the first of his class to earn a star to become brigadier general. It was Gloria who approved the AFP Generals recommendation for him to have that star.

    It’s been confirmed by a reliable source that BGen Lim tried to persuade Gen Senga CSAFP to withdraw his support but that the latter refused.

    Lim is kept in his quarters for the moment and not detained in prison.

    There are still a few generals whose identity are not known to the public today who have seriously expressed their sympathy for Lim’s ideals.

  13. MLQ3,

    Palace spin that they foiled a coup d’état was preposterous and technically wrong!

    By tradition, coup d’état is the violent overthrow of the government launched by the military but which could be aided and abetted by civilian components of the Republic. To say that they foiled a coup d’etat means that the violent overthrow had been initiated by the military or a component of the military.

    Contrary to Palace spin and innuendoes, BGen Danilo Lim, when he approached CSAFP Senga to persuade him to withdraw his support was technically espousing mutiny and not a coup d’état in the same manner when Gloria and her husband had persuaded Gen Angie Reyes to commit mutiny by withdrawing their support for the Erap government.

    That the mutiny might have later on generated into a coup d’état is another matter but at the time Lim was arrested, technically, the act being committed by Lim was inciting to mutiny and not a coup d’état. Palace spin that they FOILED A COUP D’ETAT is absolute nonsense! There was no physical evidence that Lim had launched a violent assault on Gloria’s government so, how could they foil something that had not even started?

    That there may be grounds to believe that a coup d’état might have been launched by Lim remains to be seen – Gloria’s government and her spin masters have to prove that Lim had sequestered military logistics and ammos for the purpose of a violent overthrow. Until then, the only threat to Gloria’s goverment was a general who tried to incite his superior to commit mutiny.

    Incidentally, two of the most well-known proponents of a coup d’état was Gloria and her husband when they encouraged and gave firm backing to a military general to launch the violent overthrow of the Erap government.

    It was Gloria’s favorite general BGen Espinoza, former Marines chief and the supplier of the infamous Marines’ helmets (that got Admiral Wong, former FOIC later into trouble with the Marines for denouncing the Espinoza helmets) who would have led a violent coup d’état against Erap had Angie Reyes not been able to persuade Major Service Commaders to agree to withdraw support.

  14. I’ve never heard of the tribune. I don’t know anybody who reads that or knows that exists so who cares.

  15. I read the link. “Shut down” seems to be an exaggeration. The police just took copies of a mock-up issue (whatever that means) and copies of photographs.

  16. We subscribe to the Tribune and Malaya. That their offices were raided or visited by the police, is extremely disturbing.

  17. MLQ3,

    Just read an Inq7 newsflash “PRESIDENT Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo’s state of emergency declaration was not an overreaction, but rather a preemptive move that prevented possible violence and bloodshed, according to Chief of Staff Michael Defensor.”

    What a load of utter, complete bull!

    This is an example of the most convoluted statements that only this dimwit Defensor is truly capable of.

    Really? The Emergency declaration prevented possible violence and bloodshed? What about the poor demonstrators who endured violence and were blooded in the aftermath?

    Obviously, the SEO prevented violence AGAINST Gloria’s government but Defensor must at least be truthful: IT DID NOT PREVENT GLORIA’S GOVERNMENT FROM COMMITTING VIOLENCE!

    How extraordinary that this government should create such spins and persuade people that it is not over-reacting?

    Gloria has over-reacted because she is scared. There’s nothing wrong with that but this government should be honest enough to acknowledge this instead of resorting to baloneys.

    On hindsight, Cory Aquino, a widow, is the bravest and the most courageous of all the leaders the Philippines had these last 20 years; she may be accused of poor governance but one thing she cannot and never be accused of is cowardice.

    I remember an incident when she went South to speak with Nur Misuari. Her PSG Chief at the time (Gen Volt Gazmin) who was accompanying her didn’t want to leave her alone with Nur for physical safety concerns. Cory asked Volt to leave her alone with Nur and was without close military protection. That was a display of great, raw COURAGE, something that Gloria will never, ever possess!

  18. ang daming pulis. hirap maniyempo. nandun lang sa kabila. nakakakaba.

    (pero asenso, may napadaang taga-REUTERS, international exposure tuloy. haha)

  19. yes, there are excesses but likewise there are startling revelations…as in the cases of gloria’s venable and dubya’s ports deal…

    NO to watchdogs being turned into puppies!

  20. MLQ3

    Must have back up blog. write more and encourage more people. I think the bloggers could be next.


  21. prelude to GMA declaring a state of panic! to borrow the phrase from MLQ3, those so called bombs exploding in jolo and near malacanang palace was enough to rouse attention that something was about to happen.

    i do agree that there was no actual coup attempt, the scenario was exaggerated by GMA and co. it was quite well planned all GMA and co. had to do was declare a state of emergency on the eve of the edsa anniversary, with all the anti govt rallies expected, anticipated and forthcoming.

    a newspaper has been shut down with the possibility of several more to follow including radio and tv station

    we are a country with a supreme court under the GMAs leash, a country with its congress and its armed forces bastardized and corrupted by our leaders with a senate trying to distance itself from GMA yet ending up “inutile”





  23. what’s all the fuzz for the tribune.it’s just another opposition newspaper.
    useing press freedom to defend the tribune is a waste of time for a newspaper that does not have anything to contribute to building the nation.
    there is better tiolet paper then the tribune!
    How can people spreading venom be so undespensable?

  24. I thought we were living in a democracy. But with this so called state of emergency, it looks like we are going to be living in a Nazi state. The PNP’s statement that they were going to issue guidelines for the press goes against our Constitution. The raid to the Tribune is just the beginning and that’s the scary part.

  25. joey, today’s opposition rag is tomorrow’s admin favored paper; just as today’s admin propaganda organ is tomorrow’s endangered opposition rag. you want the freedom to say what you want today, even tomorrow? defend even those you disagree with.

  26. sorry manolo,that is a nice line taken from somewhere.
    how can an opposition that you yourself are not to happy about be tomorro’s future of sorts.
    manolo, i know you are a great freedom lover.who is not a freedom lover?
    but freedom can only be lost when we used it recklesly.
    honestly manolo if i fill my freedom is threatened.i would say it’s thretened by those insisting on their’s
    because they add to lives difficulties.
    manolo naman, sana you have better taste on where your beating your future.
    just because you & many others can’t stand or deal w/ the present administration does not mean the present administration is doing it all wrong.
    everything in life swings two ways.
    if the administration shold do the right things so do we have to do the right things.
    critizing it & looking only for the administrations faults will make us all losers.
    i can understand it’s not easy to deal w/ shit.
    but if we wanna grow, we all have to think deeper & have a wider vision of things.
    if not we get stuck in so many details that makes life miserable.
    while in the mean time others move on.you insted gets left behind.
    manolo, your a great writter & i admire you for that.
    i’m worlds away compared to you.
    but you lack something.
    maybe it’s the connection between theory, idealissim to connect w/ reality.

  27. MLQ3,

    Re The Unlawyer’s comment

    Spot on! Why aren’t military officers and men taking the brunt of the charges?

    Tell you why? Coz there’s no solid evidence! The panic act was based on an imminent imminence of an imminent immince of an imminently imminent coup.

  28. “I began to sense faintly that secrecy is the keystone of all tyranny. Not force, but secrecy … censorship. When any government, or any church for that matter, undertakes to say to its subjects, ‘This you may not read, this you must not see, this you are forbidden to know,’ the end result is tyranny and oppression, no matter how holy the motives. Mighty little force is needed to control a man whose mind has been hoodwinked; contrariwise, no amount of force can control a free man, a man whose mind is free. No, not the rack, not fission bombs, not anything — you can’t conquer a free man; the most you can do is kill him.” Robert A. Heinlein

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.