The Mandate of Heaven (concluded the next day)

“Unity Walk”

“Solidarity Walk”
Same walk, different caption. A sign of the state of confusion at the Palace. Is it just me, or or are these pictured (from yesterday, the so-called “solidarity walk,” swiftly retitled “unity walk” at the Palace; by the way, see abashet joey on the President and PhotoShop) too creepily reminiscent of the End Days for Estrada, when he, too, tried to show his administration wasn’t beleaguered, by trotting out his cabinet?
Who among them is in or in the official family? The Inquirer editorial yesterday asked, Is it Neri next? and today it says it’s Panic time.
Trot, trot, clip-clop, tick-tock. What do you get?
A horse gone wild: Adviser calls Arroyo ‘luckiest b*tch’.
That’s just karma for what must surely have been a Palace factotum-released tusongbaboy YouTube video, featuring what seem to be wiretapped conversations between Jun Lozada and Joey de Venecia.
The Financial Times reports the President may be losing her fondness for playing the China card. I’ve begun rather interesting scuttlebutt of an intriguing kind, involving a government commitment to relinquishing our claims to the Spratley Islands in exchange for investments. But nothing firmer than that.
The ancient Chinese believed that the “mandate of Heaven†was revealed by tangible signs, such as flood or famine. Such misfortunes were indications that the legitimacy of a ruler was waning. Confucius elaborated the idea further, and taught that the “mandate of Heaven†was dependent on knowing the moral order of the universe, and demonstrating it in the six relationships that govern superiors and subordinates (i.e. minister to prince, friend to friend, teacher to student).
These relationships are evident in the various groups bestirred by recent events.
The Action for Economic Reforms is holding a presscon-forum on “The Godmother and the Philippine mafia” on Friday, Feb. 22 9:30 am to 12 noon at the Sta. Ana Room, 3rd Floor, U.P. College of Law. On the same day, February 22, The Law Student Government Coordinating Council, composed of the Student Councils of the Ateneo Law, UP, UST, FEU-La Salle and UE Schools of Law will be holding various activities (see i’m NOT a stop along the way. i’m a a DESTINATION for details). And Simbahang Lingkod ng Bayan has a forum on Feb. 23 (with regards to the Ateneo, read the concrete steps proposed by Simbahang Lingkod ng Bayan in their statement, as well as those proposed by the Ateneo’s Department of Political Science in its statement (the question then becomes, of course, what if government refuses to do anything?). On Feb. 25, there will be a “Concert for Truth, Accountablity and Reform” at the Ateneo from 4-8 pm (for information contact Ms. Reese Fernandez Programs Head, Team RP Tel: (02) 426-5657 <reesefernandez@ yahoo.com>)
Starting February 24, it seems Masses “for Truth vs. Corruption” are going to be held, sequentially, in Adamson University, the University of Santo Tomas, de la Salle University, and then Miriam College.
In recent weeks, the political landscape of the Philippines has been shaken because of one man, Rodolfo Noel Lozada, Jr., and his past proximity to Romulo Neri, Jr.
Both are of Chinese extraction; I have even heard that Romulo Neri, Jr. practices a form of divination, the I Ching. At this point it seems to me, whether consciously or not, both consider themselves Mandarins.
The Analects of Confucius, L. Giles translation.
The first two extracts concern definitions of good government. The first involves the “five excellent things” and the “four evil things”:
Tzü Chang asked Confucius, saying: What are the essentials of good government?â€â€The Master said: Esteem the five excellent, and banish the four evil things; then you will become fit to govern. â€â€Tzu Chang asked: What are the five excellent things?â€â€The Master replied: The wise and good ruler is benevolent without expending treasure; he lays burdens on the people without causing them to grumble; he has desires without being covetous; he is serene without being proud; he is awe-inspiring without being ferocious.â€â€He is benevolent without expending treasure: what does that mean?â€â€The Master replied: He simply follows the course which naturally brings benefit to the people. Is he not thus benevolent without expending treasure? In imposing burdens, he chooses the right time and the right means, and nobody can grumble. His desire is for goodness, and he achieves it; how should he be covetous? The wise and good ruler never allows himself to be negligent, whether he is dealing with many men or with few, with small matters or with great. Is this not serenity without pride? He has his cap and robe properly adjusted, and throws a noble dignity into his looks, so that his gravity inspires onlookers with respect. Is he not thus awe-inspiring without being ferocious?â€â€Tzü Chang then asked: What are the four evil things?â€â€The Master said: Cruelty:â€â€leaving the people in their native ignorance, yet punishing their wrong-doing with death. Oppression: requiring the immediate completion of tasks imposed without previous warning. Ruthlessness:â€â€giving vague orders, and then insisting on punctual fulfilment. Peddling husbandry:â€â€stinginess in conferring the proper rewards on deserving men.
The second related extract involves the tangible signs of good government, and the things that can be dispensed with, and the thing that absolutely cannot be dispensed with:
Tzü Kung asked for a definition of good government. The Master replied: It consists in providing enough food to eat, in keeping enough soldiers to guard the State, and in winning the confidence of the people.â€â€And if one of these three things had to be sacrificed, which should go first?â€â€The Master replied: Sacrifice the soldiers.â€â€And if of the two remaining things one had to be sacrificed, which should it be?â€â€The master said: Let it be the food. From the beginning, men have always had to die. But without the confidence of the people no government can stand at all.
Then two extracts in a similar vein, on the means to maintain public confidence, and the means to instill harmony in the people.
A simple rule of thumb concerning the hiring and firing of officials:
Duke Ai asked, saying: What must I do that my people may be contented? – Confucius replied: Promote the upright and dismiss all evildoers, and the people will be contented. Promote the evil-doers and dismiss the upright, and the people will be discontented.
A similar reiteration concerning promotions:
Chi K’-ang Tzü asked by what means he might cause his people to be respectful and loyal, and encourage them in the path of virtue. The Master replied: Conduct yourself towards them with dignity, and you will earn their respect; be a good son and a kind prince, and you will find them loyal; promote the deserving and instruct those who fall short, and they will be encouraged to follow the path of virtue.
And then, an extract pointing to the importance of precision on the part of policy makers:
Tzü Lu said: The Prince of Wei is waiting, Sir, for you to take up the reins of government. Pray what is the first reform you would introduce?â€â€The Master replied: I would begin by defining terms and making them exact. â€â€Oh, indeed! exclaimed Tzü Lu. But how can you possibly put things straight by such a circuitous route?â€â€The Master said: How unmannerly you are, Yu! In matters which he does not understand, the wise man will always reserve his judgement. If terms are not correctly defined, words will not harmonise with things. If words do not harmonise with things, public business will remain undone. If public business remains undone, order and harmony will not flourish. If order and harmony do not flourish, law and justice will not attain their ends. If law and justice do not attain their ends, the people will be unable to move hand or foot. The wise man, therefore, frames his definitions to regulate his speech, and his speech to regulate his actions. He is never reckless in his choice of words.
And what about wrongdoers?
Chi K’ang Tzü questioned Confucius on a point of government, saying: Ought not I to cut out off the lawless in order to establish law and order? What do you think? -Confucius replied: Sir, what need is there of the death penalty in your system of government? If you showed a sincere desire to be good, your people would likewise be good. The virtue of the prince is like unto wind; that of the people, like unto grass. For it is the nature of grass to bend when the wind blows upon it.
In sum, then, in the face of wrongdoing on the part of officials, considering the things that make for effective government, and which weaken it:
Confucius rejoined: Ch’iu, an honest man hates your hypocrite who will not openly avow his greed, but tries instead to excuse it. I have heard that the ruler of a state or of a clan is troubled not by the smallness of its numbers but by the absence of even-handed justice; not by poverty but by the preresence of discontent; for where there is justice there will be no poverty; where there is harmony there will be no lack in numbers; where there is content there will be no revolution. This being the case then, if outlying communities resist your authority, cultivate the arts of refinement and goodness in order to attract them; and when you have attracted them, make them happy and contented. Now you two, Yu and Ch’iu, are aiding and abetting your master; here is an outlying community which resists your authority, and you are unable to attract it. Partition and collapse are imminent in your own State, and you are unable to preserve it intact. And yet you are planning military aggression within in the borders of your country! Verily I fear that Chi-sun’s troubles will come, not from Chuan-yü, but from the interior of his own palace.
Do you need someone else to tie this all together for you? Including the abstract at the end of this entry? Thank you, Left Flank.
The question then… as my column for today is titled, is for people to see what the Minimum and maximum goals they want achieve from hereon up to 2010 will be. (someone who takes the court of public opnion seriously is Chances in the Starlight).
Blogger un suplemento metafisico a la realidad de mi existencia slices and dices things very well:
The administration shall be presumed innocent until they are proven guilty. However, its actions do not allow me to do so. The anti-truth mafia has scribbled so much manipulation of evidence, information, and facts that the presumption of innocence has been vaporized. Instead of testifying for the “truth” the co-conspirators of the anti-truth mafia has been hiding behind what they call “executive privilege.” The administration has pushed the envelope too far. It is now at the edge of a cliff and is desperately holding on by trying to cover-up all pieces of evidence that may eventually lead to its demise.
Thanks to the anti-truth mafia’s propaganda, Jun Lozada has been accused of harboring nothing but hearsay which they claim is inadmissible in courts. However, he does say these statements under oath, thus he has with him what is called testimonial evidence. “A woman who has been raped can send a man in jail just with her testimonies.”(Escudero, 2008) In addition, he seems to be very consistent with his statements unlike some of the anti-truth mafia. Jun Lozada was also accused of being corrupt – which he admitted with a smile, and I think this makes him all the more credible – He was part of the project, he was an insider, he knew the goings-on of the ZTE-NBN deal.
Jun Lozada is neither a saint nor a hero but he has with him the truth. Whether he came out to tell the truth for the sake of truth or for some other ulterior motives – which is hard to think of considering that his testifying in the Senate has put him in a very precarious situation. If he were to lie, what motive was so great that he was willing to put himself out of the pan and into the fire almost voluntarily? Testifying has put Jun Lozada between the legendary monsters Scylla and Charybdis. He is currently between hell and the deep blue sea. In whatever perspective I try to view the course of events for Jun Lozada, I can’t seem to find any advantage that he might gain in testifying. In fact, he was “forced” to do so – as with the summons, this implies that testifying is not advantageous for him. On the other hand, he might be thinking of a career in showbiz. If that is so, then he is making a good start. We are probably watching one of the best soap operas ever made.
It doesn’t matter whether or not the bringer of truth has been tainted with wrongdoings in the past. What is more important is that he has the truth with him and so his voice shall be heard. The substance lie in the statements, not in the personality. An honest man will voluntarily take off his clothes to show that he has nothing to hide; while a thief would wear layers upon layers of clothes just to hide whatever it is that he has stolen.
In the rest of the blogosphere, the Ateneo Mass last Monday was covered by Don’t fight darkness. Bring the light, and darkness will disappear and by Mahal ko Pilipinas!!!!! and …strawberry-filled donuts… (Lozada’s nephew) and with photos by Blahg, Standing in Motion, neo saicon, sj while thatniceboy gives an insight into the minds of those who remain detached. There were other activities, too: it’s a yummy world recounts attending a Mass at the Redemptorist Church. highwayse7en8 doesn’t like Masses with political aims. Neither does priest-blogger Bangor to Bobbio. On the other hand, Postcard Headlines in Cebu describes the first glimmerings of people bucking the view that the city is “GMA Country”.
As for Lozada, lifelong learning compares what he’s doing to debriding dead tissue; pine for pine compares folksy Lozada and Abalos stories; as for views, there are the pro: there’s lecheplan, and four-eyed joie’s thoughts as well as Verities of a Writer’s heart; con: you can’t be more straightforward in expressing skepticism than under deconstruction; and neutral: preMEDitated wants to believe, but doesn’t yet. dino! dedicates poetry to the man. rl_829 thinks he’s a dead man. My Mirror to Reality undertakes an interesting experiment: what if Lozada is 100% good, or what if he’s 100% evil?Law and ICT and mga kababalaghan sa buhay ko take opposing views on whether Lozada’s phone being hacked is believable or not. Vincula points out we should give thanks for the demolition team assembled by the Palace.
There are, of course, continuing views on what’s going on. Katataspulong some time ago, wondered if people really want decent officials, or whether the tangled web of corruption makes for a comfortable pigsty for everyone. jmtaylor has a bone to pick with politicians in general. Romwald’s Realm tackles the dynamics of corruption: subtle rebel runs down a list of the ironies of life (politics-wise).
Lawyer notes of marichu c. lambino points out that the government keeps corroborating the testimony of Lozada (tart comments on Gaite’s admitting he gave Lozada half a million in Alleba Politics and Bong Montesa’s weblog ). The Mount Balatucan Monitor is certain of the outcome of government efforts at damage control. The Warrior Lawyer takes a similarly skeptical look at the Ombudsman, etc.
And yet… there are those who prefer to stick it out with the administration because they continue to loath those who oppose her more. In a sense, the “same-same” message track of the Palace continues to work, as Walk This Way echoes:
I mean, yes, the First Gentleman is a little piglet. No doubt about that. But please don’t tell me that all the politicians pursuing this issue aren’t little piglets either (below). Getting little greasy slices of pork from projects like the NBN is modus operandi in ANY administration – it’s no secret to us and it’s no secret to the senators doing the grilling. It’s been the modus operandi for decades! Where else would ANY administration get money to do things like, oh, give to senators and congressmen for their election campaigns? Senators and Congressmen don’t come for free, ya know. Tip: instead of looking at the noisy ones, let’s try and count who are the quiet ones in Senate and Congress. Perhaps they are quiet because they already were given their pieces of the pork. And it’s only the squealing ones that are upset because they didn’t get theirs. Hence, if it’s all just piggies fighting piggies over pieces of pork that they just pass on to other piggies, then it’s just politics in the end. Period. Philippine politics and governance is sick, that is as obvious as obvious can be. But will this Jun Lozada scandal be the catalyst for the great changes that need to be made? Ha! Great changes will be done in this society through small ways and on a person to person basis. Paradigm shifts don’t happen through Senate hearings. Trust me, this “moral revolution” WILL NOT be televised.
Do I think corruption should be addressed? Yes. Do I think getting rid of Gloria will solve this issue? No. Do I agree with JDV that a moral revolution in government should be pursued? Yes. But will that revolution come from Senate and from Congress or from JDV himself. Hell no. Parehong baboy silang lahat. So that’s why I’m ignoring the politics and protests. And judging by their sad rally last week (Please. Makati Business Club, Black and White Movement, Cory Aquino et al. More people attended the Beyonce concert than your rally), I think others are too.
A senior citizen, My Life in the Philippines, is ambivalent about removing the President from office but for different reasons:
I consider GMA having lost the “Moral Authority” to continue on as President until Yr2010. Granting PGMA credit for a resurging Philippine Economy does not justify Moral Bankrupcy. While our kind of Democracy has made ours a “Country-of-Laws” (where Public Issues ought to be decided in the heirarchy of our Courts), a collective judgement of a fully-informed Citizenry (by a Free Press) in the Court-of-Public Opinion does carry a strong moral value.
…On the other hand, I believe: (1st) That People Power I & II have not brought about a “Better Philippines”. I consider “Graft & Corruption,et.al” as an Ethical Problem which have not and could not be remedied by street-mandated Political Solutions – i.e. People Power Change-of-Presidents; (2nd) That the Church (visibly represented by the Religious Priest & Nuns in the Streets, in Congress, in the Courts) have failed in its Pastoral Work of enlightening and encouraging Political Leaders to move away from the evil of Greed-for-Money – thus necessitating “Graft & Corruption”.
…Given all of the above, I contend that it would be good for our country for PGMA to continue in office until Yr2010. But, she must take the lead for all in Public Office in a “Moral Crusade for Good Government”. She (together with all who would follow her example) could redeem herself/themselves in the Public Eye and erase all doubts about “Hidden Wealth” by a public demonstration of giving-up 90% of their respective Family’s Private Wealth accumulated during their entire Political Career. I liken this “Moral Crusade” to a “National Cleansing” following the Korean Example – not too long ago.
The senior citizen blogger isn’t alone: UST student james_cartmire says something similar:
i got into some debate though when i opened that my position, no matter where investigations lead, was for gma to definitely finish her term in 2010. i said that even if everything leads to impeachment, the impeachment process, being a political process, will just muddle and broker ties with old faces, further preventing genuine reform efforts, and that the whole gma vendetta might even ruin the promise of a new start in 2010. i also echoed what neri purportedly said (based on the supposed lozada document i received trhough mail) that an impeachment buzz would just increase government spending (i.e. malacañang diverting public funds to buy out representatives, opinion leaders and power brokers) and that all these crises could lead to another economic slump. after almost breaking to a 39-level before the nbn hearing resumed, just yesterday, the peso-dollar exchange rate was again P41 to $1.
And so, some are ambivalent about resignation or People Power (see paperchimes.net). Or the Catholic Church: Brown SEO asks some tough questions, as does Philippine Commentary opposes People Power. On the other hand, Ceci Da Supastar reproduces the soul-searching appeal of a member of the Left, who says they can’t afford to miss the bus again:
Why should we work with them? Because we all want the same short term goals, which are the end of the GMA administration, the reform of a corrupt system, and free and fair elections. We may disagree on our broad ideologies, but we agree that these are the immediate obstacles to our various long term goals.
But, perhaps more importantly, if there is anything we should have learned from our EDSA experiences, it is that we want bargaining chips when this is all over so that we can influence the future. And those bargaining chips only come in the form of weight of our participation and the numbers we draw.
And yet… Lunasandwich says people are increasingly interested, but still stumped on what to do:
I take this as a good sign, of the keen interest of the people to know how others feel or think about the issue. What has really struck me though is the disenchantment and shared distrust for almost all people in government…
It seems the enormity of the problem  graft and corruption (which does not end with Arroyo’s removal from office) and the deeply rooted social malaise  is not lost on the people. Sadly, while the problem has long been identified, at the moment, people still seem to be at loss on what to do.
Marvelous photos of the Senate hearings taken by Bro. Ceci of La Salle: Ceci’s Corner.
And here’s something eloquent by Yogon Multiplies: let’s remember to do the small stuff, too. lovelife?! – eto self supporting! ^_^ writes about school pride.
Thank you to the reader who sent me a copy of this paper: The Integrity of Corrupt States: Graft as an Informal State Institution by Keith Darden. Interesting abstract:
This article argues that corrupt practices such as bribery and embezzlement, which scholars have previously assumed to be evidence of the breakdown of the state, may reinforce the state’s administrative hierarchies under certain conditions. Drawing on a cross-national analysis of 132 countries and a detailed examination of the informal institutions of official graft in Ukraine, the article finds that where graft is systematically tracked, monitored, and granted by state leaders as an informal payment in exchange for compliance, it provides both an added incentive to obey leaders’ directives and the potent sanction of criminal prosecution in the event of disobedience. Where graft is informally institutionalized in this way, it provides the basis for state organizations that are effective at collecting taxes, maintaining public order, and repressing political opposition but that may undermine the development of liberal politics.








Hi mlq3,
From your above write up regarding Lunasandwich’s concern
This needs to be seriously discussed and analyzed. While the events of our nation seem to be speeding up, civil society yet have to discuss the safety net of ANY possible post-administration collapse.
The social political leeches looking for an opening to exploit our country further, whatever their persuasion, should not be allowed to sit in governance ever again. At the very least an excellent third party check and balance system must be established outside the confines of government power and politics.
whatever happens, whether GMA be removed or not, we must not accept ANY old face as our leaders again. i can even go and vote for fr.ed for president going by his track record as governor of pampanga.
i could only count by the handful politicians who are worthy of their office. and not one of them is a senator or a congressman. two are governors, four are mayors, and a few are city councilors.
If we don’t want to see the ancien regime once more, we should opt for revolution.
¡Basta Ya! ( Enough is Enough!)
It’s Time To Say ENOUGH!
As if the spins, half-truths and outright falsehoods of the spin doctors were not enough.
As if the lies about the Hello Garci scandal were not enough.
As if the switching of the ballot boxes in the Batasan was not enough.
As if the squandering of billions of pesos in a litany of scandals since 2001 was not enough.
As if the shroud of secrecy that binds this administration was not enough.
As if the violations of human rights and the disappearance of Jonas Burgos and many others were not enough.
As if the gross neglect of the very poor (except on election time) by this administration was not enough.
As if the Palace bribery of congressmen and governors was not enough.
As if the kleptocracy of Jose Pidal was not enough.
Now ,after all that, we have the abduction of Jun Lozada and the subsequent cover-up .
Now we have had enough!
WE,FINALLY,HAD ENOUGH!
¡Basta Ya!
If ZTE is like Watergate, then a word to the wise: don’t castrate the government too well, or it will invite a reaction. And, beware of the younger ones, especially the defense ministers and chiefs of staff!
Wow!!! You guys are talking already of a post GMA scenario here. It seems like the only acceptable thing is for GMA to be ousted. Do you really think GMA is the source of all what is wrong in our society?? Mark this post, if GMA is overthrown there will be more problems and all of you guys/gals are back posting lamenting the fact the the new powers that be have hijack the new government without implementing real reforms.
blackshama, would you go as far as a revolution as bloody as france’s?
i’ve always held that only by destroying every vestiges of the current phils can we create a new one.
magdiwang, there won’t be any hijacking if snap elections are called. erase all the leaders we have till now and vote NEW ones in. erase the comelec we have now and put credible people in. then have snap elections. worried abt where to get the budget? there’s some sitting prettily at the president’s discretionary fund right now, plus some hefty pork barrel earmarked for the thieves this fiscal year. worried abt a junta? as long as all of us are united, people power will make those generals think twice. that or we face civil war. which is more the merrier for us. much more so if the war gets drawn out for years.
let filipinos then fight for the phils they truly want. then let’s see if after that filipinos still don’t have a sense of country.
Gloria’s resignation is also acceptable. She might just see it as for the good of the country. (eyes rolling).
I really admire your optimism in our society. Im also for the ideal scenario but Im a little bit more realistic. Whoever will be president will not get the necessary reforms implemented. There are just too much powerful interest groups to contend with. Short of a cultural revolution, nothing will change. We should work within the system to achieve the necessary reforms. This might be slow and protracted but it is the only alternative IMHO that is less disruptive to our fragile economy.
Everyone please be advised: Rumor has it that GMA is planning on bribing local officials to stage a fake rally in her favor on the EDSA anniversary, Feb. 25. She wants people to believe that she still has the support of the silent majority. Let’s spread the word and not be fooled by yet another tactic of bribery and lies!
I agree that what we have learned especially from EDSA II is that changing the president is not enough; there must also be some basic institutional changes. It is the system itself that is broken, it allows corruption and limits the space with which good people can work to bring benefits to everyone.
Thus, the answer is a movement to not only remove GMA, but to institute an agenda of reforms that fix elections and corruption in the bureaucracy.
Speaking of post-GMA scenarios: Please, when we succeed and GMA steps down, for the love of all that’s holy, DONT celebrate. This isnt a victory. It means we failed yet again to make this work. It means for the past 7 years, good citizens did nothing and just shrugged their shoulders when GMA’s administration started abusing its powers.
The Palace has started the ‘Revenge of the Sith’ as the PNP filed a perjury charge against Jun Lozada’s wife while the Bastusan Pambansa comtemplates stripping the Church and religious groups who become involved in politics of their tax privileges.
Jeg, totally agree with you. Very sad really. She has to go, and she will go.
Carlos Celdran’s (Walk this Way) blog entry demonstrates how too much skepticism leads to a breakdown in one’s moral compass.
Moreover, we must be careful even of the currently “good” leaders we might have. A third-party check and balance system must be established to prevent the failure of post EDSA II government from repeating again and discourage new officials from “backsliding” into the old ways of corruption and abuse of power.
Not only Gloria and a lot of her cabinet failed; even Senator Joker Arroyo who for the longest time I used to consider as a true patriot and defender of human rights failed. The lack of adequate third-party check and balances may be the reason for this; or maybe its simply his choice.
Check out my link with new article and photo: Trying to understand Joker Arroyo, “to be a Vader or not to be a Vader, that is the question…”
The problem with a revolution, Blackshama & Devils, is that once you start it, no one controls it. We could end up like France…or we could end up like Cambodia.
carlos celdran:
i think celdran is channeling austero. why call on them to commit suicide when it’s the arroyo administration who has betrayed our public trust and abused it’s power?
It’s too bad that we don’t have politicians in the mould of America’s paleoconservatives Pat Buchanan, Ron Paul, and Duncan Hunter.
To borrow from a Pat Buchanan 2000 campaign ad, “Team Unity and Genuine Opposition are for sale.”
The question then becomes if The People want to exact their power. And because there lacks the moral authority on both sides, the indecision of the people is the result.
Revolution cannot take place if there lacks moral authority because for it to happen, there must be a stark contrast from the before and to the after. If Noli is the after, is this really a revolution?
It seems that the Arroyo Administration and the Opposition are both sides of the same coin. But let’s hope that there are still a few good men and women from both sides of the political fence.
“Short of a cultural revolution, nothing will change. We should work within the system to achieve the necessary reforms. This might be slow and protracted but it is the only alternative”
Actually this is a solution that hasn’t been tried yet. Only because the more POPULAR options has always been Fiesta Revolution (the EASY path is always the preferred choice of people who are short on IMAGINATION).
On the cynical side I bet we still need more bloodshed and more bombings before everybody realize the kind of government they replaced Estrada with. Of course there will be more flat denials or in the words of Freud defining Defense Mechanism per-se:
* Denial: Refusal to accept external reality because it is too threatening; arguing against an anxiety provoking stimuli by stating it doesn’t exist; resolution of emotional conflict and reduce anxiety by refusing to perceive or consciously acknowledge the more unpleasant aspects of external reality.
* Distortion: A gross reshaping of external reality to meet internal needs.
* Delusional Projection: Grossly frank delusions about external reality, usually of a persecutory nature.
Seems like Joker Arroyo is reeling with one or all of them. ^_^
Benign0, they tried a ‘cultural revolution’ in China. See where that led them.
that’s the fun part you see. at least we’re giving our country a 50-50 odds of going away like france
and is our country’s state today any less diff than cambodia? take away all the facade, our country is exactly like cambodia.
besides, i have more faith in the filipino people than you. that’s why im willing to gamble on a bloody revolution. it’s total change or bust
I hope you’re not serious about wanting a revolution because that’s the last thing the country needs. Any change must be through peaceful means.
On a lighter note, I was watching Wheel of Fortune (Kris Aquino’s) and Jun Lozada’s name was used as a clue.
Fearless forecast:
I see this whole addiction to Edsa “revolutions” as something that will keep on spiralling — the periods in between these circuses getting shorter and shorter.
At some point a president will come along — a veteran of several of these — who will know enough to use a HEAVY hand to crush any form of “revolution” violently if necessary.
Maybe Gloria is this president.
Walang sisihan. Pinoys, and our silly addiction to this fantasy called “people power” asked for this.
“Benign0, they tried a ‘cultural revolution’ in China. See where that led them”
The Philippines is NOT China, in case you haven’t noticed.
I was talking to a friend earlier today about what to do given the increasing public anger over the ZTE scandal.
My idea basically is this: all of us turn up the heat, not just on GMA, Neri and the Cabinet, but also on our congressmen so that they’re compelled to impeach GMA later this year when the ban expires. Yes, I know they’re crooks too. But if we do it well enough and they realize that their re-elections are at stake, the optimist in me thinks it can work.
When GMA is impeached, we can ask the Senate to make sure the trial lasts for a few years to prevent Noli for assuming the Presidency (and have the benefit of running for the Presidency as an incumbent in 2010). They can convict her maybe shortly before the campaign period starts in February 2010.
This way we not only expel the Malacañang mafia, we also prevent a Noli presidency. The best part is, if we stick to the Constitutional processes, I do not think our economic growth would be adversely affected. And our people will not have to suffer as much from having been again betrayed by its leaders.
What do you guys think?
Is this a good thing, Benigs? It’s fine if that person’s a Lee Kwan Yew…but if it’s a Somoza? a Noriega? an Idi Amin? Does clamoring for good governance merit this kind of “leader”?
It’s no brainer. That simple.
Saw the news report with this “walk” and laughed at the possible conversation between the president and sec. neri…
Neri: hawak na kita sa leeg ngayon…YOU will do as I say…
Gloria: tumahimik ka na jan…ginagawa ko na nga lahat ng hiningi mo!
Somebody is still addicted to heavy handed mailed fist dictatorships
“Is this a good thing, Benigs? It’s fine if that person’s a Lee Kwan Yew…but if it’s a Somoza? a Noriega? an Idi Amin? Does clamoring for good governance merit this kind of “leaderâ€Â?”
I didn’t say it is a “good thing”. I’m just saying that we may have it coming.
Where do you see this string of street “revolutions” leading to? If another one comes along that is successful, that will simply make Pinoys more addicted to it.
And we all wonder why corruption is so rampant in Pinoy society. It’s because by its ver inherent nature, Pinoys are ADDICTED to shortcuts and instant gratification.
If Gloria were as shrewd as I think she is and knowning now in hindsight what complacency in the face of growing unrest can mean for an incumbent (ask Marcos and Erap), I’d say the thing to do would be to quell this forcefully asap.
A look at the bigger picture – the Chinese Connection.
1. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ybz8M1TRc6o
2. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9KYrTXK2pKE
3. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tcQaa6IUiR0
4. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdImiG0lFgk
You’re right, Benigs. She’s been Marcosian so far, so we may be in for another 20 years of GMA rule, courtesy of a little bit of Martial Law.
Or not. She’s gotta do what she’s gotta do, and we’ve gotta do what we’ve gotta do.
benigno/mike,
My God, you guys are scary. Patriotism is the virtue of the vicious – are we prepared to be vicious?
I don’t think we should rule out the scenario that Benign0 is proposing. After all, someone did say that Gloria is ‘evil’ (which Benign0 considers as being ‘shrewd’).
mike,
Haven’t you noticed? We are already under Martial Law! Look at all the familiar check points (choke points), arbitrary detention cases, disappearances, illegal raids, wire tapping, surveillance. Democracy is an illusion expertly weaved by the powers that be.
An eerily familiar scene. They must have the same choreographer, but where is the suntok sa ere ala Erap?
People Power is the legislative and political process in a direct democracy. We have a representative democracy, a very different sort of thing. People power is like av-gas in a cigarette lighter. It gets the cigarette lit along with the frontal lobe areas. It is elitist not because of the elites that take part, but because of vanishingly small fractions of people actually needed to accomplish regime change. At Edsa Dos it only required One Guy who happened to be wearing the Black Robe Costume of the Chief Justice. But what exactly was his authority to be there and not presiding at the Impeachment Trial? Haha! Edsa Dos wasn’t even “People Power”! It was a putsch by Davide.
There has only been one real People Power. I salute that. But like being born, we really should do revolution only rarely in a nation’s life. Lifetime revolution is for the other kind of religious fanatics–Jomaoists!
I oppose people power now because we have a marvelous chance to set everything right by doing what we failed to do in 2001: impeach and convict a President.
Remember folks there is a HANGING Senate. A House impeachment move is sure to end in conviction and victory for those who sign on to it. Nov 15, 2008 is the 7th anniversary of Erap’s impeachment. Let JDV get Lakas to decide whether they want to go down in flames with kampi in 2010!
December 7, 2008 would be a good day to start an impeachment trial and ship the whole Supreme Court to the Senate during the trial where the Sgt at Arms can keep an eye on them!
I don’t think that scenario is going to happen naman…wala nang communist threat eh. People and the international community won’t take it naman…hanggang 2010 lang.
Here’s a really grim scenario: invasion by a foreign power.
DJB Rizalist,
Strangely enough, I cannot help but agree with you on this one. Lets try IMPEACHMENT again, this time lets do a better one. If that fails, lets try again. I cannot bear the thought of another extra-judicial ejection, a mob can easily run awry and uncontrollable, I cannot imagine putting friends and brothers alike in harms way.
Some have forgotten some other historical events in history … What would have happened if East German state police and soldiers clashed with their civilians during the fall of the Berlin Wall; or if the civilians have fomented a violent revolution while they tear down the Berlin wall?
I understand however that there is a possibility that great violence may break out and but it would not come from the civilians (of course this evil administration, following the Marcosian doctrine, can put in “moles” and “agent provocateur” among the protesters to instigate violence from their ranks but that is another story); that is the reason why prayer, reflection and ultimately correct reflected action is necessary.
It is not only meant for humbly requesting from our Supreme Creator for deliverance and protection from this evil in society, it is also meant to ask for guidance to realize the right moves in specific situations. This is the way towards practicing true communion, unlike the present day physical communions (using bread and wine) which have become routine habits to some and have lost its true meaning to others.
Mita,
Check out the you tube videos (7:55). We are already under invasion, with consent pa. While we are busy fighting each other, we are weakening by the day.
DJB, your comment above meanders across different positions:
1. first you criticize people power,
2. then you say what happened in EDSA Dos was not people power,
3. then you salute EDSA (1986) as the only People Power,
4. then you discourage any repeat of people power and conflate advocates of People Power with the communists
5. then you oppose people power because of what happened in EDSA Dos which (you first said was not people power.)
Please clarify, thanks.
kabayan,
By EDSA, I mean the peaceful redress of grievances, by all means lets continue. What I fear is the possibility of a violent end as our sitting president is no Marcos nor Erap – she may not have the restraint for shooting down people which is typical of those who have no experience in the martial lore.
At times, the most dangerous people are those who have never been in a fight, they have others fight for them, as they will not have any qualms of hurting others.
” A House impeachment move is sure to end in conviction and victory for those who sign on to it.” -DJB Rizalist
Why would the house majority allow an impeachment of GMA? The mere threat of a people power will not make them change their minds and an actual people power makes the impeachment moot and academic.
One obstacle we need to overcome inorder for impeachment to have a chance though – the congressmen. Is it at all possible to dissolve congress first? The way I see it, as long as they can close ranks, use their numbers, the battle is won even without the conflict. These guys are Sun Tzu enthusiasts without being aware of it.
DJB,
I never really found out. Are you anti-GMA? or just anti-EDSA? or anti everything with the red motif?
Ramrod, i don’t think the Constitution provides a mechanism for dissolving Congress.
Woe to the nation that does not raise its voice save in a funeral, that shows esteem only at the grave, that waits to rebel until its neck is under the edge of the sword.
–Khalil Gibran, The Nine Woes
FOR LAWYERS ONLY (and those who like to peek)
Why impeachment is not necessary. This article changed my mind about it, check it out.
http://www.senpinglacson.proboards83.com/index.cgi?board=investigation&action=display&thread=1203511056&page=1#1203511056
cvj,
It might help if we fine tuned our approach some more. Like taking away their power base, congress and local government, or at least weakening it.
ramrod wrote:
True, Gloria has never been in a real firefight seeing real wounds and real dead people, that makes her simply decide willy-nilly on the value of life and scoff at the results of real suffering. She has insulated (or was insulated at the beginning) from the pain and suffering of a real war. I agree, this makes her doubly dangerous. At least grudgingly I admit that Marcos had experienced the rigors and horrors of battle and witnessed the suffering of the families of the dead and wounded.
Sometimes when people say something about “lets go to war (as in a gunfight)” to settle differences, I just smile wryly since obviously they really don’t know what they’re talking about. “Rambo” and a lot of glorified war heroes make it look enjoyable and easy, but what they never really focus on the movie is what the family of the dead “enemy” went through after their breadwinner got cut up by a supposed Hollywood “hero”.
Ramrod, as far as weakening GMA’s power base, on the legal front, what i can think of is for someone to file a case in the Supreme Court that removes the prerogative of disbursing pork barrel funds from the Executive on the grounds that it compromises the independence of Congress and the principle of Separation of Powers. Hopefully, that would make for a more independent Congress.
Now would also be an opportune time to revive our hosts previous suggestion of a nationwide signature campaign to shorten the President’s (and Vice-President’s) term of office. It would be a genuine People’s Initiative.
I’m referring to Manolo’s suggestion of Institutionalizing People Power:
http://www.quezon.ph/?p=875
“On Wednesday, one of the President’s economic advisers referred to her as the “luckiest b*tch around” during a forum attended by businessmen and business leaders.
“Alam naman nating lahat at alam naman ni Presidente na masuwerte siya. [She] may be a b*tch but she’s the luckiest b*tch around,†said Albay Gov. Joey Salceda.
The off-tangent remark, which Salceda acknowledged as a joke, was made as he discussed economic growth issues at the Ateneo Center for Economic Research and Development.” – ABS-CBNnews
Mickey and Dato will surely be offended with this joke, they will jokingly be called sons of the _________.
ace,
I hope someone got a video of that, that would make a nice ring tone!
ram,
something to look forward to…
“Institutionalizing People Power” hmmmm, I wonder why we didn’t pick up on this?
EDSA Dos was filled with Bands and Free Drinks and Goldilocks. Who wouldnt go for free booze and entertainment? I went there. I drank san mig lite and ate goldilocks for free, so does my friends kaya nga kami pumunta eh. Nakikishout na lang ng Erap resign!
Kung ganyan din ba ang mangyayare sa susunod na rally e d mas maraming pupunta.
Ideology my ass. We were having fun for free. Pakikibaka sa korupsyon came later.
“Where do you see this string of street “revolutions†leading to? If another one comes along that is successful, that will simply make Pinoys more addicted to it.”
=====================================================
This is the reason why I dont like snap election, resignation and peopel initiative at all. Just like peopel power, his can set a really bad precedent that pinoys will be addicted to. Not to mention manipulation of some politicians or even businesmen and the church for their self serving interest.
Gloria should be allowed to finished her term until 2010 or remove her through impeachment.
Edwin,
That was just you. Not all people are like you, you know, some are responsible and most have faces to match.
Ramrod:
Hmmmm! Interesting angle: usurpation of public office.
Well, I’m all for bringing her to justice via constitutional means. It’s when these avenues have been subverted (e.g., impeachment impossible due to purchased loyalty of congressmen; investigation hobbled by questionable E.O. 464; Ombudsman compromised by personal loyalty) that People Power becomes a last alternative for expressing outrage against misgovernance.
ace wrote: (regarding Salceda’s description of Gloria)
On one description that she’s “lucky”, maybe, but luck tends to run out. For the other description, I would not debate with Salceda on that.
The siRaulo in DOI said that Neri should resign because Neri never denied saying that Gloria was evil. He simply said he just could not remember. I’d like to see how Grand Inquisitor siRaulo would handle Salceda’s statement.
Kabig ng dibdib ba Gov. Salceda?
The American Jihadist makes a lot of sense. If one wants to strengthen representative government you start by going through the institutional process of removing the President. She has to be separated from the Office of the President.
In the U.S. a president can pardon a suspected criminal even before one is charged.
In the Philippines high government officials should be tried till they get convicted or acquited.
Every one poor and powerwill be good for the political full should be held to account.
The process itself will be good for the political economy.
The one lesson that Philippine culture will have to learn and absorb is accountability and being held to account.
The is essentially critical for the micro-minority that is the middle class who are predominantly centrists and right of center rightists.
The left is still trying to recover from Jomaism and they can supply the mass base for effect.
For the Catholic Church, the perfect storm that induced Sin to call out for people to go to Edsa for Edsa I was sorely lacking in Edsa II. Sin stretched the pretext to push for Eraps resignation. For a short time the theocrats decided Eraps faith.
Justice Puno’s decision in declaring that Edsa II was a simple matter of removal of the Chief Executive by people power and was intra constitutional is still hard to take.
Erap had no business being a President but his removal destroyed the constitutional process. Big Mike and GMA simply deepened and broadened the destruction of constitutional processes. They both propagated the theocrats by even establishing a office for religious affairs. They created their own cabal of mullahs and ayatollahs. Now everyone is competing to get their own mullahs and ayatollahs to lead a mass movement. The taste and flavor of Edsa II has turned sour. A more critical eye has been focused on Edsa I. Edsa I primarily responsible for the return of democratic space. The economic mismanagement continues unabated. The country is now almost totally dependent on the export of human resource to keep the economic accounts in positive balance. It is obviously not sustainable as the previous economic problems have seriously undermined the capacities of governance that has turned the Philippines into a cannibal state. Every man and family is out for himself and themselves. When state institutions fail man will revert to his natural state. Self preservation and the kanya kanya system becomes the ideological model.
The U.S. constitution implicitly upheld racism and slavery for almost a hundred years. The U.S. still is ideologically working itself out of that doctrine.
In the Philippines the theocratic influence of religion is still dominant in political discourse.
This time organizing a mass movement to push for reforms is the perfect vehicle for pushing for another impeachment process.
The Philippine constitution needs desperate reworking. It has been seriously compromised.
It is clear from the photographs above that the military and police have now achieved cabinet status. Erap’s walk did not have a military police component.
Yesterday Ambassador Kenny was photographed with MILF Head Murad.
In parts of Mindanao the Philippine State has almost disappeared.
The mechanism for putting a new set of faces simultaneously into Congress and Malacanang is well-defined. Elections!
Kung parliamentary na ang Pilipinas, hindi na kailangan ang snap election by the people  vote of “no confidence†by the honorable members of parliament na lang ang kailangan. A motion of no confidence is a parliamentary motion traditionally put before a parliament by the opposition in the hope of defeating or embarrassing a government.
Ngayon, to prevent crises of the state by ensuring that whoever is head of government has enough support to govern, siguro kailangan kopyahin ng Pinas-parliamentary ay ang mother-country Spain which use “Constructive Motion of No Confidenceâ€Â. In Spain (also Israel and Germany), a vote of No Confidence requires that the opposition, on the same ballot, propose a candidate of their own whom they want to be appointed as successor by the respective head of state.
“Institutionalizing People Power†hmmmm, I wonder why we didn’t pick up on this?”
Actually everything else di not pick up, di ba? . If you back since very start of these scandal an dami ng suggestion s at advocacies na lumabas. So many groups has been form and so many ideas good or bad came. did any one of them picked up at all?
One reason I see is that there is no credible leader at all on those advocacies that came out.
So who will lead these institunalization proces of people power. Manolo? Nope, I cannot even stomach most of his very biased writings and entry on this blog. I dont think he is capable of leading any movement or advocies for now. He should demonstrate some form of objectivity and maturity first before he canbe a leader.
If there is one that really picked up , its the sucessful demolition of each other. Yes ,the mudslinging was so sucesfull to the extent that we are now having difficulty in identifying who is credidle and who is not. One that will be acceptabel; to both side and to the majority of the people. The anti Gloria her will be very quick to point finger at Gloria who destroyed the gevernment institutions but actually they too is very much guilty of such destruction .
mike,
Thats why this fight should have been fought on many fronts, not just in the arena of public opinion. We may enjoy ridiculing Gloria or any of her goons but whats that going to achieve “sticks and stones…”
I’m still hoping that the opposition will come up with a real united effort in effectively removing Gloria without us having to play around with the “mob phenomenon,” as what the end will look like if we have a build up of outraged people and the government’s unpredictable response.
There is a way if we really put our heads together, one is charging her of usurpation, take out the doctored election returns, follow the paper trail, the “hello garci” should have been thought through.
Another front would be her power base, congress, and local government, these should be neutralized. All of us, per district, per municipality – lets bang on the doors of our respective congressman, mayor, even governor!
Revisit EO464! Is that something the senate-in-aid-of legislation can get into?
Why not take a look at Manolo’s “Institutionalizing People Power?”
Also, another EDSA type removal of the sitting president may not put us in good light with the international community, whether we like it or not we live in a global community.
People Power need not be a bad word, really, can we change it to Filipino Power.
Two bicolanos on the side of GMA, one is joker, the other one is joking.
Make the Presidential Term to be every 3 years (and no person can be chief-of-state for more than 6 years, combined).
Or even more “institutionalizing of people power” is to make the Presidential Term to be every 2 years (6 years as President, max).
Not good enough??? Make the term 1 year!
UPn, have you read Manolo’s suggestion?
rego,
Manolo will not think of leading at this time and one has to make a stand on something. There’s no such thing as objectivity unless you view life as a theoretical existence. You have to cast your lot somewhere.
For me, all these unpleasantries are just smoke clouding real life threatening issues – real lives that are threatened really. The end result I’m looking at is the release of those arbitrarily detained, abducted and still missing, a solution the street children, street people issue, hungry people I pass by everyday living under a bridge, poor sick people the hospitals had to push away because they had nothing to pay with plus hospitals without any meaningful equipment and medicine. If I had the power to disburse 500K without batting an eyelash, it would go a long, long way. But as it is, I have no resource of that kind.
So I’m open to suggestions short of storming the palace and dragging Gloria out by the hair – I don’t want that either. But we need to hurry, peoples’ lives are at stake!
And we all wonder why corruption is so rampant in Pinoy society. It’s because by its ver inherent nature, Pinoys are ADDICTED to shortcuts and instant gratification.
——————-
Funnies thing I’ve read in a longtime — about corruption. And where’s the basis for the statement that we are addicted to shortcuts and instant gratification? And what is the cause?
Babala? Yet another group has just sprouted. But look who is doing the talking? Leticia Ramos Shahani? Credible ba sya? I dont think so. Just like teh others lam ko na kung saan hahantong ang grupong eto.
Makes me wonder ? bakit kaya hindi na lang mag stick sa iisang grupo ang mga eto. Isisa langnaman ng Puntirya at gustong mangyari. Ang mapaalis si Gloria sa Malacanang. Why not just joing Grand Alliance Agaisnt Gloria. Or simply just join United Opposition?
By his actions, I do not trust FVR
United Opposition. I pray that it becomes a description not just a group’s name. Have we ever had one? The need for a united, singular effort is there, but some choose to splinter.
The reality on the ground is that we are being invaded by foreign forces already, area in focus – Spratleys. While we are busy going at each others throats, we are losing our sovereignty. That is real…
I wonder at what point in time did China begin ignoring The Analects.
Here we have a wonderful treatise on leadership and good governance and yet we cannot say that the Chinese take them to heart knowing how corrupt and immoral their business dealings with Burma, Somalia, Zimbabwe (to name a few) are…
cvj:
The mechanism for putting a new set of faces simultaneously into Congress and Malacanang is well-defined. Elections!
I humbly believe that my proposal: elections every 3 years to be superior to the PeopleInitiative documentation process proposed in Manolo’s “Institutionalization of People Power”.
Mine is so much easier to understand (by fishermen in Jolo, farmers in Negros, labanderas in Batac, and yes, the population of metro-Manila) that it — elections every two years — allows better participation by the population.
Just think again between “garci” and today and you have… every 3 years.
Mine is also geared towards getting the process done better — getting the vote out from all communities of the country, by any and all (not just those who have the level of sophistication and the time for “people initiative” paper flows). And the Honasan-wannabes can’t say “but it takes too long to get the Malacanang trespasser out!!!”.
There is also a minor detail of UncleSam money being offered so that the Philippines can get the votes counted fast and correctly, maybe it can be used to buy ZTN equipment.
USELESS, USELESS
Whatever we say or do, Gloria will not leave the palace, she can’t, she believes that she is ordained by God!
Watch this if you don’t believe me…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYwF88arI64
ramrod said:
Yes and I think the self proclaimed Son of God, Quibuloy, said she’s “heaven mandatedâ€Â(***canned laughter***)
If indeed Gloria believes in Quiboloy’s preachings we are all in deep shit. She will listen to no one as she looks at us as lost, misguided souls, and that only she alone can lead us to the promise land, to bring us closer to God! Hey, Quiboloy said God told him personally? So whatever she does, she has is insured safe conduct pass through the pearly gates already!
Honestly, how can you reason with fanaticism?
yes. look at what two peaceful revolutions got us.
ang sinungkit ng matulin, walang kaabog-abog na tatapunin
di kasi pinaghirapan kaya di rin pinahalagahan.
ah oo, may mga naghirap sa unang EDSA. ilan sila samantalang lumabas lang ang milyon ng patapos na?
sa news clip kanina, pinakita ilang saglit flash back ng EDSA II. the people were chanting “Gloria, Gloria, Gloria!”
perhaps that got into Gloria’s brain and made her think the people there were really clamoring for her instead of just a change in leadership. anybody wag lang si erap.
the next revolution should not have us chanting names but ideals: PAGBABAGO! PAGBABAGO! PAGBABAGO!
to the admin: dnt worry, critical mass will be reached in 2010. have your heads ready.
Wonder why Joey Salceda, governor of Albay and long-time supporter of Gloria uttered those words. Oppps. Freudian slip. He didn’t even bother apologizing afterwards. Trouble in Gloria’s camp. The pols are starting to smell opportunities for jumping ship.
devils/madonna,
Watch this. Hindi na matatakot si Gloria, lakas ng kakampi niya…
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYwF88arI64
devils/madonna,
Watch the video I posted (11:05) hindi na matatakot si Gloria, ang lakas ng kakampi niya!
ramrod,
‘So I’m open to suggestions short of storming the palace and dragging Gloria out by the hair – I don’t want that either. But we need to hurry, peoples’ lives are at stake!’
Take out the most vulnerable member of the Family.
sa unity walk ni erap, namataan ko si mar roxas. naks! erap man to the bitter end pala ‘tong si mr. palengke!
harinawa pagkatapos ng rebolusyon, wala sana akong makitang familiar faces sa bagong gobyerno. pls lng enrile, magpalibing ka na. simula martial law mo pa pinahihirapan ang bayan.
at least easily identifiable na kung sino ang ha-huntingin di ba? ULAP. Congress. GOCC heads.
make your list, check who’s naughty or nice. itaga mo sa bato. bastille is now truly, inevitable.
Grabe. A video speaks a million words. And people were calling Trillanes, Lozada. et al messianic?
Gloria is worst, God directly saying she is the mandate of heaven?
If this is what we’re up against, devils scenario is looking more and more viable…
‘
Check your EQ. it is abnormally high. Better still cut your coffee intake.
walang rule of law dito sa pilipinas! binaboy na ni arroyo ang saligang batas ng pilipinas. putang inang rule of law yan! sino si doj sec. gonzales? boses na ng bayan ang nagsasalita! 70% na taong bayang ang ayaw kay arroyo! nagisilayas na mga mamamayan dahil sobrang katiwalian at mamamatay na lang tayo sa gutom kung maghahantay na lang sa gobyerno para mapabuti ang kalagayan ng ekonomiya!
ramrod,
Nyahahaha… Nutter that Pastor C. Quiboloy! And Gloria kept on saying praise the Lord, praise the Lord when he was recounting his “vision”.
@ramrod,
Oh my god, that video is hilarious! Akala ko walang tagapagmana sa trono ni Willie Almeda…..buti nalang meron sina Quiboloy at Fr. Suarez to continue entertaining us with voodoo.
The Cat,
Look at the video posted 11:05, if you’re rational or a christian you’ll respond with shock. If not, you’re well, good thing you’re not in Pinas, but we need your help though.
And we all wonder why corruption is so rampant in Pinoy society. It’s because by its ver inherent nature, Pinoys are ADDICTED to shortcuts and instant gratification.
=========================================================
No! We are led by LUNATICS in government! You want proof? Try a whole video.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYwF88arI64
So Neri said he couldn’t remember saying GMA was evil, huh? Why on earth didn’t he just say outright that he never said that? Even though the spotlight was trained on him, surely he knows how to mince words properly (being Arreneow trained). But I guess its safe to say safe answers. And that is the root of the problem in our society, where a spade is not called a spade.
ramrod, i did not just wake up one day and said to myself, wow, i’ll go post at manolo’s blog and be a doomsayer. my prediction takes events to its logical conclusion.
1. we are now at the point wherein groups previously divided over whether to give gma a chance or not are now coming closer to agreeing that 6 years is more than enough of a chance given her. and if she keeps harping on to give her more chance, we can wait till hell freezes over, giver her 10 or 20 years, but the fact still remains: she had those 6 years and she used them to enrich her family. how much more benefit of the doubt should we give her?
2. congress is now poised for charter change.
3. there is but one tiny chance (a sliver actually) that all anti-arroyo forces would actually agree on one post-gma scenario. critical mass would be reached agreeing GMA has to go. but that’s as far as unity goes.
4. comelec is still the palace’s lapdog.
5. congress would convene into a constituent assembly while the people are sleeping. lower house would unilaterally vote it doesn’t need the senate. wham-bham-ty. protest rallies would gather more fierce than ever to force the lower house to back down (like it did the last time).
6. the iron fist will now show itself, swipe away those rallies, swoop down on all comm stations (cellphone, internet, tv, radio – all down) gma will appear on govt owned TV, wearing red, warning all “destabilizers” that she will not allow this country to go to “communists” insurgents.
7. the new pinoy generation (post martial law babies) never having experienced martial law all cower in fear. martial law veterans are either dead or aging.
8. the “sham plebiscite” can now proceed. nothing beats success other than success, gma will think to herself as the new parliament is approved “overwhelmingly” by the filipino people.
9. we end 2009 with a whimper. those who kept harping on abt waiting for 2010 ate their words. wtf? too late!
10. now it becomes glaringly clear. the policy of human exportation has made this country a wasteland in more ways than one. all the best and brightest, gone. this is the land of the forsaken. and vultures are feasting at the seat of power. the poor and uneducated has not the will nor the capability to organize a resistance. but they feel hunger. and they are legion. and tnx to the catholic church, they multiply exponentially. all poor and uneducated.
11. 2010 marks the flight of the rest like bencard (who also ran at the eve of martial law). my prediction thus begins.
idk how many years, or how long the filipino people can take it. it took 300 years for spain, 17 years for marcos (correct me manolo if im wrong), 3 years for erap…
is the filipino people evolving out of their passive selves?
one thing is certain. and that is bastille at the hands of the hungry legion. for no one can stay and reason with a man who has devolved into man’s ulterior mode: survival of the fittest.
my story doesn’t end there of course.
that’s just the beginning. in his column today manolo said the worst options: social implosion and/or a filipino pol pot.
not removing gma today leads to that road eventually.
after the mob lynching, the revolutionaries would be divided into two groups. one advocating an end to bloodshed and restoration of democratic institutions, the other advocating more purges. the latter group carries the filipino pol pot.
civil war will rage.
the filipino diaspora is now complete. thousands become refugees.
luzon will become the stronghold of one group (more likely the pol pot group), visayas of the other group. mindanao breaks away and tribal wars start dividing that island into islamic states.
whoever wins in that civil war will not call themselves filipinos. the true filipinos have now become like the jews. no real place to call home.
now pray i am wrong.
Ramrod, that footage in April 25 2004 (where she says ‘Praise God…Praise God’) was just a few weeks before Hello Garci. Maybe her sense of being anointed gave her the stomach to go ahead with tampering with the election results.
devils, cvj,
Strange, just tonight someone sent me this post:
“I really hope that I’m wrong but I think GMA has a contingency plan (an evil one) just in case a people power revolution materializes in Manila, she will flee to Mindanao(Davao in particular) and will force the issue using the Congressmen, Governors, Mayors including Quiboloy and his congregation. Even Mayor Duterte was quoted that they will secede from Luzon and the Visayas.
Last Sunday, Norberto Gonzales met with the governors of Mindanao in Cagayan de Oro city and to quote some excerpts from the Sun Star report( a Davao Newspaper):
“In the meeting, the governors agreed to assert their collective and individual authority to resist any unconstitutional and illegal moves to oust or force to resign President Arroyo.
Davao del Sur Governor Douglas Ra. Cagas, in a text message, said they agreed not to recognize in their respective provinces any “usurper†who benefits from the ouster of Arroyo.
It was Compostela Valley Governor Arturo “Chiongkee†Uy who revealed that Gonzales also discussed with them the possibility of the President staying in Davao region for a week to meet with Mindanaoan governors.
But he denied that Arroyo is seeking refuge here in Mindanao as anti-Arroyo sentiment in Metro Manila grows.
“Para lang daw makausap niya yung buong Mindanao officials. The governors of Mindanao also suggested that the President should put up a Malacañang of sort here.â€Â
This explains the Quiboloy connection.”
ramrod, gma would perish quicker in mindanao.
DevilsAdvc8,
GMA’s titles
The President of the Philippines
The Chosen One
The Resident Evil of Malacanan
Big Sister
The Filipino Pol Pot
“set-up”…buong arroyo regime and cronies na set-up!
official stand ng malacanyang…”set-up”….hahahaha…
ibig sabihin nila na na set-up sila ni mr.lozada? bobo naman nila! buti pa si neri, original…”i can’t remember”…at si gov. salceda, another arroyo man…”she’s the luckiest bitch around”…nothing funny at all…sana matakot tayong lahat baka ma set-up tayo!
GMA as Pol Pot? Pol Pot was a leftist-to-the-Nth-degree whose propaganda of levelling the playing field and the classless society, when put to action, became not only humiliating but shoving bayonets and putting bullets into the middle-class and the rich. GMA as Pol Pot? I can not see her ordering the population of Alabang or the stockholders of San Miguel Beer to be marched to Payatas and there, bayonetted or buried alive.
Unfortunately, a few people in this blogthread has not yet benefited na umaapaw, but … (music, please!!!):
And the money kept rolling out in all directions
:
…..
Now cynics claim a little of the cash has gone astray
But that’s not the point my friends
When the money keeps rolling out you don’t keep books
You can tell you’ve done well by
the happy grateful looks
Accountants only slow things down,
figures get in the way
Never been a lady loved as much as __
UP n student,
Most of the people buried in Pol Pot’s killing fields are not rich people. I also don’t believe that Pol Pot was a communist. He was just plain nuts.
yeah I agree, there was nothing ‘leftist’ about pol pot, he was a psychopath…
mayro-on nang Internecinesa manga Oligarhs. Si Mrs. JVD nag breakaway na, sinisisisi daw manga Oligarh na nagmidnight Cabinet pinagulohang nang Proxy Presidente FG, kaya pala daming Utang na Lo-ob si GMA. Yan isang Insider na nam. Sabi naman nang Palasyo sa-an ang EVIDENSIYA? ang galing talaga nang Palasyo Paulit paulit lang, tumatabla rin ang Tehcnique nila, dami rin nakumbinsi. Sin-o ba may sabi na kailangan Ulit-Ulitin mo lang, epektebo rin yon parang Placibo..
GMA seeking refuge in Mindanao? From the frying pan to the fire! % :wink %
JDV and moral renewal eklat. Sarili nga nyang distrito, hindi man makolekta basura at maayos ang kalsada. JDV hindi ka na national ‘leader’, umuwi ka na ng Pangasinan at ayusin mo sarili mong bakuran. Baon ni inam.
GMA seeking refuge in Mindanao?
In the event of an upheaval in the capital, its also plausible that GMA may seek refuge in Cebu City. Not only does it have the reputation of being “GMA country,” it also houses the Malakanyang sa Sugbo or the Malacañang in the South. Likewise, militant and civil society groups can barely mobilize a thousand here during “big” protests.
I would agree if anyone praises Pol pot for efficiency. Of the thousands who entered is famous fields, less than 30 are known to have survived.
He was a damn cheapskate — most were executed with pickaxes to save bullets.
And his “chosen ones” included homosexuals (favorite of practically all liberators-with-moral-superiority), plus:
-professionals and intellectuals – in practice this included almost everyone with an education, or even people wearing glasses (which, according to the regime, meant that they were literate);
-ethnic Vietnamese, ethnic Chinese, Cambodian Christians, Muslims and the Buddhist monks;
- non-farmers : former urban dwellers (who had not starved to death in the first place) were deemed to be guilty of by virtue of their lack of agricultural ability;
-anyone with connections to the former government or with French, USA, UK, Vatican, Japan… any foreign government.
A PolPot running loose in Philippine politics will unite the country. There is no PolPot yet in a mayoral- or higher elected position in the Philippines.
PolPot, in 1949 or 1950, joined the French Communist Party, the most tightly disciplined and orthodox Marxist-Leninist of Western Europe’s communist movements.
No, PolPot did not have a business degree from the University of California-San Diego nor an economics degree from Georgetown University/WashDC.
Folks,
The fact is the People have always known the Truth, at least those beyond a certain age and below a certain income. But the Right to Know is vastly overrated and does not always lead to knowing the right thing to do. And even then, we are always seduced by the EASY thing to do, which usually involves throwing out the Constitution. As for the LEFT, that’s the ONLY thing they KNOW to do, or WANT to do: thrown out the Constitution. They don’t want democracy to work, because that is precisely their argument: that it cannot work. By rallying and pushing the situation to boiling point, they are the ones preventing the right thing from happening.
After Jun Lozada has so carefully built up a moral high ground from which to stand above the Palace and on which to rebuild our democracy, the people power diehards are pushing it all off a cliff with rallies and demos.
Better na nga the signature campaign of MLQ3. If only we valued our IDENTITIES enough to allow the govt to print cards proclaiming them, signatures might mean something. But no. the Organizers want us to use our BODIES instead of our BRAINS.
They want the People to be Mob, not a Movement.
The want People Power to be an Insurgency, not an Institution.
There already IS such an institution that enshrines, organizes, limits and deploys People Power, with the wisdom of many peoples, not just of those who claim to have invented it somehow in 1986.
It is called the Constitution, a magnificent plagiarism that those Barrio Mechanics refuse to treat a simple Social Contract and would rather construe it as Bible.
When I say impeachment, I also mean the impeachment of a Chief Justice, or at least, SOME Justice, say for bribery and corruption. It’s the only way to re-establish the SOLE and EXCLUSIVE power of the Congress of the People in the matter of Accountability of Public Officers. I remind you all, the Supreme Court has the largest number of such officers at 15.
In the Writs of amparo and habeas data, the Supreme Court Justices are all impeachable for culpable violation of the Constitution. In their defense they will have to prove that these WRITS are not NEW RIGHTS that they have established using constitutive power, contrary to the rule making power provision they used. They have to prove they have not increased, decreased or modified our substantive rights. yet in habeas data, I calculated they just gave 20,000+ consanguine and/or affine relatives of mine the RIGHT to KNOW my data. Also look it up. These are among the most corrupt instruments in courts all over south america.
They need a taste of People Power that they cannot strike down. For in Accountability, they have no Jurisdiction. Congress does.
One thing many people don’t know about the Supreme Court is that actually nothing is final there when it comes to “transcendental” cases. ANY past decision can be reversed by a future Supreme Court.
Estrada v. Arroyo cannot stand! It is logical carpentry that does not stand up to even the merest moral scrutiny of first year law students.
It is not enough to be RIGHT. It is more impt to be FAIR. That is if we want to be JUST.
“You’re right, Benigs. She’s been Marcosian so far, so we may be in for another 20 years of GMA rule, courtesy of a little bit of Martial Law.
Or not. She’s gotta do what she’s gotta do, and we’ve gotta do what we’ve gotta do.” — Mike
And this thing that “we’ve gotta do” is yet another hollow-headed street “revolution”. As I said before, gimme a break. Pinoys are losers either way.
If this “revolution” succeeds, it will merely feed Pinoys’ ADDICTION to moronic street circuses.
If it fails… well now; let me count the number of ways that Pinoys will fall flat on their faces:
(1) It may merely make Gloria’s resolve to crack down even harder on dissent (something Pinoys probably deserve given our penchant for stupid shortcut solutioneering).
(2) It will make the military even more loyal to the incumbents.
and, more IMPORTANTLY:
(3) The laughter at our standup comedy in the region will grow even louder and rumbunctious.
“My God, you guys are scary. Patriotism is the virtue of the vicious – are we prepared to be vicious?” — ramrod
Are Pinoys prepared to be spanked considering we’ve been such cry-babies for the last 20 years?
“After all, someone did say that Gloria is ‘evil’ (which Benign0 considers as being ’shrewd’).” — cvj
OBJECTIVE people call her “shrewd”.
SUPERSTITIOUS people call her “evil”.
“Strangely enough, I cannot help but agree with you on this one. Lets try IMPEACHMENT again, this time lets do a better one. If that fails, lets try again.” — ramrod
I’m all for this!!!!
Let’s face it guys, as Mr. ace quoted Salceda as saying: “[She] may be a b*tch but she’s the luckiest b*tch around”
Firstly, she is IN POWER with a generally loyal military (for someone so allegedly unpopular). She could sick the BIR’s auditors on all these Makati Business Club bozos to muzzle them all. Crank up “routine” health and safety compliance checks on certain businesses run by “uncooperative” characters. Maybe even do a probe on certain Church “practices” — you know, shed some light on certain priests’ “personal” activities or re-visit certain “shelved” cases on certain clergymen/womens’ “inappropriate” behaviour. Bury everyone in paperwork, kung baga.
Now THERE’s some really great ideas there (Madam President, are you listening?
). There’s lots of things that can be done within the Law and with the national coffers at your disposal (these are all State processes by the way — processes that should be happening in the first place rather than these “Senate inquiries”).
Pinoys at heart are suckers for authority — even if we like posturing and chattering about being ‘rebels’. When we see someone step up and use Power with CONVICTION (which is not the same as saying it be used ‘properly’ or ‘improperly’), we line up behind him or HER and follow like sheep. Gloria is in the perfect position to step up and do just this — CAPITALISE on the relatively strong loyalty of the Army to her, consolidate this, stem any indication of this loyalty eroding, and wield this power with CONVICTION.
A vacuous people deserve to be ruled with an iron fist.
It is this CONVICTION that Pinoys deserve — not the limp-d1ck street “revolutions” and the ironic Catholic masses in the campuses of the very schools that produced the Philippines’ oligarchs that that old-fart romantics like Salonga (who could barely lift his head to speak out) harp on about.
Second, she is presiding over statistically prosperous times (as her luck would have it). At the end of the day, that’s what it’s all about. As Bill Gates said: Money is the best scorekeeper. We may carry on like hollow-heads (like we’ve always done for the last 50 years) about the pleasant nature of Pinoys, our hospitality, pristine beaches, and colourful jeepneys (I’m trying not to laugh here), but at the end of the day, if Pinoys continue to leave by the drove to wipe Western European arses at the other side of the world, we’ll be nothing more than a pathetic footnote on the pages of mankind’s history books.
And Third: Do we have a CREDIBLE replacement? I’m sure Erap loyalists are vindicated AND hopping mad about his ILLEGAL removal back in 2000.
Go figure. History will simply repeat itself and SOME of us will be laughing (along with the rest of the world) all the way to the bank.
Mark my word.
-
Blogger fired from CNN for having a blog:
wwwdotdeusexmalcontentdotcom
why should i be shocked. almost all charismatic organizations claim tat they have direct land line to heaven.
some posters here state that if glma is going to be ousted, it is God’s will.
what’s the difference?
and why sre those people with rage in heart attend masses with clenched fists.
what i know is when you come to the house of God, you even love your enemies.
joey salceda calling GMA a bitch was a ploy to show people anyone, esp. Neri, can call her anything and suffer no consequences…
i think all these scenarios are WAAAY over the top…ang sama naman ng tingin nyo sa kapwa nyo. Di lang magnanakaw. mass murderer pa???
why not recruit FVR, former president whose administration had the least scandals amongst the living presidents, to dialogue with GMA for the people, get her to do the reforms we want, and assure us she will step down in 2010. FVR may not be palatable to all but we cannot argue the fact that he had a relatively stable term as prexy AND he has shown her enough goodwill (ok and bad) in the past so as not to antagonize her…
he wants to be an elder statesman, let’s test his mettle now…once more.
Looks like Malacanang feels the need for another shot of its antidote to the people’s ardor.
“Executive Director Ray Roquero of Lakas-Christian Muslim Democrats (Lakas-CMD) Wednesday told the Philippine Daily Inquirer that the stage was being set for De Castro to be endorsed by Ms Arroyo as her presidential candidate in 2010.”
From PDI report: VP De Castro seen as Arroyo’s 2010 bet, says Lakas exec (First Posted 02:19:00 02/21/2008)
It might cool some people’s ardor, but I dont think the ploy will fly in this crowd (Im talking about those who frequent this blog.) I hope De Castro isnt stupid enough to fall for it.
People seem to keep on talking about the “critical mass” to get another people power going. Wouldn’t it be easier if we people power our representatives to withdraw their support for PGMA. Wouldn’t it be easier if we divide the country to conquer it?
These congressmen are OUR representatives so for heaven’s sake REPRESENT us! The congressmen are a vital part of this evil web. It is high time for this people to realize where their power comes from, NOT GLORIA but US! We need to breathe down their necks. If we go by IMPEACHMENT then we need to buckle down and do our job. These congressmen will have to vote according to OUR WILL or they will be removed from office by their constituents.
Also, my skin crawls when I see JDV and family speak of moral revolution! Wow! Can you believe him? Pumepwesto na. Trapong trapo talaga!
The President basically bought the Lower House, well we need to show her that we own the Lower House and IT IS NOT FOR SALE! The government is a heirarchy and WE ARE ON TOP!
Gloria “power” that she brags so much about comes from the congressmen. If we erode her arrogance from below, she will eventually lose footing and will crumble down.
OK Lets lighten up guys…
I just saw the performace of Ramielle Malubay, the only Pinay who made it to Tope 24 in American Idol 7. Man, she is really really good and really impressed teh 3 judges. Yes including Simon Cowell.
Now for the very first time, I am going to vote in this reality show.
I just saw the performace of Ramielle Malubay
and she’s so cuu-u-uuute.
Rule of law gone to the garbage. Instead we again celebrate the emergence of rule of mob, rule of media , rule of religious.
Very sad that the instigators are at it again. I can not understand how religious(daw), men and women of cloth could be so easy to condemn people without any factual , documented evidence..it ‘s plain and simple hypocrisy.
Priests and nuns at the senate hearing looked very oa.
The 4,000 that attended the makati rally is certainly not close to even 2% of the population.
Did Jose Rizal and our other National heroes use their position/s like how Lozada did: asked by a philsar reader
“Also, my skin crawls when I see JDV and family speak of moral revolution! Wow! Can you believe him? Pumepwesto na. Trapong trapo talaga!” — Zel
Trouble is, MANY Pinoys eat that cr@p for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. May merienda pa.
Even the most vile of politicians can invoke the “word of God” and Pinoys will eat it up. This is typical of a society that has delegated all its thinking faculties wholesale to religion, ideology, and political slogans.
As an “admired Filipino economist, based in New York” noted about the kind of discussions that pervade the chattering classes of Pinoy society:
” ‘They are droll and unintelligent, focused on the trivial or the irrelevant.’ When the issues are of some significance, it’s the wrong arguments that prevail, the wrong side wins. Logic and common sense take the backseat to political arguments and the views of the poorly-educated. There seems to be some bases for her disenchantment. ”
This was back in 2000. Check it out here:
http://www.geocities.com/benign0/agr-disagr/10-comsen.html
Now step back and take stock of the national “debate” going on EIGHT years since.
You just gotta laugh, folks.
We must also include our , kabataang barangay officials, barangay officials, mayors and governors in the new brand of “people power”. Let us work within the system. Use the bureaucracy to our advantage. The religious, students, businessmen within our cities must exert force on these local officials and demand that these officials express OUR REAL sentiments and not their personal sentiments on the issue at hand.
“Rule of law gone to the garbage. Instead we again celebrate the emergence of rule of mob, rule of media , rule of religious.” – james
The ironic thing is that while the people affiliated with the above crowds constantly crow about becoming a ‘modern’ democracy ruled by Law, there is nothing more Medieval- and Feudal-looking than the sight of throngs of these cretins waving clenched fists followed by robed men and women waving religious icons in the air.
could only count by the handful politicians who are worthy of their office. and not one of them is a senator or a congressman. two are governors, four are mayors, and a few are city councilors.
Yes, i know of one- perhaps this Jess Robredo of Naga City. Anyone from the Bicol region here, please enlighten us of Mr Robredo. Our knowledge of his illustrious achievements is limited in print.
Luoy gyud si joker, kung kanus-a pa natigulang saka pa gyud nagbinuang
Pastilan, maminaw ta kay rego, usahay kinahanglan mag pahuway, dili maayo ang stress kada adlaw, kada oras!
how can people be so naive to believe these instigators!!
AbS-CBN, print-media are hopeless but priests and nuns?
but again their only difference with us is the white cloth that they adorn
james,
So you’d rather go with Quiboly huh? Go ahead, join your momma…
James, lahat ba ng pari at bishop dapat huwag pakinggan?
but again their only difference with us is the white cloth that they adorn
Exactamente, James. Theyre citizens too and have rights protected by our laws.
this letter is taken from philstar
“Dear Br. Bernie FSC and my Lasallian family,
“I would like to respectfully furnish you and our community with a copy of the statement of my husband, Deputy Executive Secretary Manuel Gaite in the light of the repeated public allegations of Mr. Jun Lozada against him.
“The words of St. Augustine �No one can claim a monopoly of the truth� are what have kept my husband and I going at this darkest hour of our family life. I fully stand by the integrity and honesty of my husband and I know he is not capable of doing anything as dishonorable as what Mr. Lozada has kept telling the senate and the media.
“It is very sad that when my husband finally got a chance to face Mr. Lozada in the senate and state the facts from his side, Mr. Lozada so easily got away with his very damaging statements in the previous days. I vividly recall how in a previous senate hearing before my husband was called to testify, not to mention in many media interviews, Mr. Lozada so freely maligned the name of my husband, saying among others, that it was my husband who told him to lie, go to Hong Kong to evade the Senate, and allegedly used the term “dilatory tactic” to orchestrate the entire cover up.
“When my husband finally got his chance to be heard in the senate, at one point, Mr. Lozada corrected himself, saying he must have confused my husband with another lawyer. And Mr. Lozada so easily got away with it, just like that, and still earned himself the description of a very credible and consistent witness thereafter.
“Last Saturday night, when my husband was not there in the “Harapan” to be able to promptly refute, clarify or correct Mr. Lozada�s heavy allegations, Mr. Lozada again so freely accused my husband, saying that the same gave him P500,000 to keep him away from the Senate.
“The next day, which was the 100th year of our town fiesta where my husband happens to be the parish centennial celebration president, was a very trying time for us as a couple, when he had to stand up in our parish and thank all those who have supported him for the celebration. Although I know how he must have been hurting inside, I never heard him utter any word to use the opportunity to air his side in the face of such damaging accusations. It was also the same time when my own La Salle community was hailing Mr. Lozada a hero in our nation�s search for truth, someone whose words cannot be questioned anymore, someone against whose words, a differing view would only be condemned.
“I have silently watched and listened to how our La Salle brothers and other members of our La Salle community, many other religious and former government leaders have repeatedly affirmed the credibility of Mr. Jun Lozada to a level seemingly beyond doubt, calling others whose words do not jibe with his story as corrupt and merely covering up for the President. Even then, I prayed I would not be tempted to pass judgment against the brothers although in my hearts of hearts, my question was how could some of the brothers who I thought knew me personally and my husband quickly judge him purely based on the allegations of Mr. Lozada?
“During the MBC meeting the other week, I learned that Dean Juico stood up for my husband whom he had known since the time of President Cory and asked the MBC to at least hear first what my husband had to say in the senate before asking him to resign based on Mr. Lozada�s very serious allegations). I was surprised to learn today from Dean Juico that it was only a couple of days ago when Bro. Armin was able to recall that Deputy Executive Secretary Gaite is my husband. It bothers me because I had thought that considering that if the allegations of Mr. Lozada are all true, the people charged would be punished; at least due diligence must have been done by persons supposedly discerning and courageously standing up for the truth.
“I know I�m not an authority in spirituality but many innocent people could be irreparably damaged through trial by publicity and even our own search for truth if our means are not as carefully consistent with our sincere ends. This is not to discredit anybody nor to criticize those who fully support the crusade for truth of Mr. Lozada as well as those who believed him completely but rather to contribute to our communal discernment of Truth for our country.
“The thing that gets me going these days, as I have said, are St. Augustine�s words: No one can claim the monopoly of the truth. Truth is neither yours nor mine. It is God�s. We all hold in our fragile hands a piece of Truth and I believe the call is for us to put those pieces together, humbly and with a readiness to hear other sides, even a contrary view, believing the best and not the worst in each other in order to build our country from where we are, however broken or in need of healing.
“This will be my first time to say publicly that my husband has served four presidents as an honorable man. And in all those times, not one president I recall can claim perfection nor freedom from any allegations. What if, by any chance, not all that Mr. Lozada is saying is true? Can we still bring back the good names of people and their families should they be later proven innocent in the court of law, or completely erase the clouds of doubt that have been sown in the minds of people against them?
“All I ask is for you to give my husband and all others concerned the benefit of the doubt and the human right of presumption of innocence unless proven guilty. Loving my husband as much as I do, I would not in any way attempt to obstruct justice, if he has truly done anything unlawful or dishonorable.
“Since I am currently serving in your august school as director of our Center for Social Responsibility and Human Development, which I consider the closest to a Center for Ethics that we have at the moment, I would understand it should you honestly feel I no longer have the credibility necessary for the good name of the Center.
“I have humbly attached for your kind attention the statement of my husband. In a way it�s our joint statement since a part of what was recounted there happened when I was there. While I informed him that I would send you a copy of his statement, I did not tell him anymore of this emotional transmittal letter from me, which I will also copy furnish him.
“I only wish good things for Mr. Lozada and the rest of us.
“Yours sincerely,
“(Signed) Mrs. Maribel R. Gaite”
In the words of the esteemed C at, paraphrased:
She his wife, what do you expect?
(But anyone who’s married would point out that husbands and wives do keep secrets from each other. I know I have. Yes, Im scum.)
Benigs, what are you saying? That if we can’t impeach GMA, we’re not allowed to feel and express outrage at her administration’s shenanigans? And that if she cracks down, it’s our fault?
Ano bang gusto mong mangyari?
GOOD NEWS!!! The economy decoupled itself from the political noise. Equities following wallstreet choppy trading instead of the drama at the senate. Did the people also decoupled itself from the corruption controversies as there are very few showing up at the rallies? Now Nograles wants to decouple the church from its tax exempt status.
This is a shallow comment admittedly but to the Harry Potter fans out there, doesn’t Neri remind you of Peter Pettigrew? Traydor na sobrang sipsip kay Voldemort. Pero parang awa naman wag gawing Harry Potter si Lozada. Please lang.
I>People Power is the legislative and political process in a direct democracy. We have a representative democracy, a very different sort of thing. People power is like av-gas in a cigarette lighter. It gets the cigarette lit along with the frontal lobe areas. It is elitist not because of the elites that take part, but because of vanishingly small fractions of people actually needed to accomplish regime change. DJB
(This is a bit late because I have just voted too . . . no, no, not in the caucuses but for Ramielle Malubay!!)
Now, I believe People Power exists whether the form of a democratic government is direct or indirect. The conception of People Power both during EDSA 1 and EDSA II was in the nature of the exercise by the people of the power of the last say, a sovereign power which underlie the colonial Constitution of 1935, the Marcos Constitution of 1973 or the People Power Constitution of 1987 (as well as the American Constitution from which our constitutional system has been modeled).
As a product of People Power, there is a fundamental drift in the 1987 Constitution from a purely “representative†government towards a “potential†yet expressly acknowledged form of direct democracy in the very first section of the article on Legislative Department (Article VI, Section I in relation to Section 32 thereof) reserving to the sovereign Filipino people, the principal, a provision for initiative and referendum as an express legislative power-sharing mechanism co-existent with that so delegated by the same sovereign to the agency of the Legislative Department. This pubescent form of direct democracy also finds expressions in Article XIII, Sections 15 and 16 as well as Article II, Section 23 of the Constitution recognizing the national role of people’s organizations, NGOs and community-based organizations and facilitating “the establishment of adequate consultation mechanisms.â€Â
If the members of the present SC are not as “elitist†as they are, there’s been a couple of opportunities (in Santiago v. COMELEC and in Lambino v. Comelec) to pullulate at least a hybrid system.
DJB, your math ignores the numbers constituting the “passive†participants.
For example, today the survey says (and I’m aware of your position re surveys) that 77% of Filipinos want GMA to resign, and if 1% of them who are so intense to brave police truncheons, water cannons, rubber or even live bullets and the natural elements and succeed in making GMA resign, it won’t be perfect science but it would be illogical (and math is logic) to exclude the “onlookers†and living room activists from the equation.
I will have to distinguish too between People Power as a process and as an outcome. As a process both EDSA I and EDSA II were a legitimately political exercise of the sovereign power of the people. Whether the final outcome was a dud or a total fiasco is another matter. It’s like legitimately electing an exceptionally gifted Marcos or supposedly egalitarian Estrada and ending up with a megalomaniac thief and a little-minded jerk.
Sorry, the paragraph of my post above is a quote from DJB’s
James, like it or not, religion exerts influence on Philippine society–just as it does in a lot of other places. It’s like socio-economic status. You probably can’t prevent it from affecting people’s attitudes.
And the leaders of the Catholic Church here are in quite a bind: they’re criticized for both speaking out too much and speaking out too little. Damned if they do, damned if they don’t. I wonder why the INC doesn’t get this kind of flak.
Abe, i agree with you that we have “to distinguish too between People Power as a process and as an outcome“. Especially since human will is involved, there is an inherent contingency in outcomes. For example, even if Erap was successfully impeached and Gloria took over via that route, it does not mean that Hello Garci would not have happened.
It is inconsistent to defend EDSA (1986) and then criticize EDSA Dos and then defend EDSA Tres (at least for those who accept it as a genuine mass action). In a similar fashion, those who criticize EDSA Dos but call for Arroyo’s ouster via people power are also being inconsistent. Because of the contingency of outcomes, all EDSA’s should be defended and/or criticized as a package.
“Benigs, what are you saying? That if we can’t impeach GMA, we’re not allowed to feel and express outrage at her administration’s shenanigans? And that if she cracks down, it’s our fault?” — Mike
Nope. How can one not be “allowed to feel and express outrage” when THAT is exactly what is already happening today?
The question is, where is this “expression of outrage” LEADING to? Another moronic street “revolution”? Or a PROPERLY undertaken regime change (i.e. via elections or via impeachment)?
If she “cracks down” it is our fault not because we did anything bad but because we did things HALF-WITTEDLY.
Regime change through street “revolutions” served its purpose once. But to have it virtually “institutionalised” as the preferred method everytime we are unhappy with a politician is the handywork of half-wits who are short on foresight and long on, well, vacuousness.
Lets face it, there are two types of bloggers, one actually does something (act on his words), the other – well, just makes up words.
If the supposedly Gloria defenders are for real – let them show it, go barricade Malacanang with yourselves or come up across the EDSA group with your own Defend Gloria movement out where we can see each other. Or maybe yet at least do something like send Gloria “We support you emails” etc. or send her more money for whatever purpose she requires.
If not, as I said, words without actions are cheap thats why its easy to come up with them.
If all goes well another EDSA you’ll say “oops sorry you’re right guys” and if not “I told you so!” Come on, cast your lot, be men, not mice!
On CBCP bashing. James et al, remember this, once you’re in your sickbeds (or deathbeds) you’ll all cry out to God. In your funerals you’d want a mass too probably? You condemn the church yet you cry out for it when the time comes.
Sickening really, contribute first before you demand!
benigno, anthony scalia,
You both are very articulate I give you that, but this is the real world – we have real people with real needs who need real results, some immediate (life threatening) and some long term. I really hope you help out a bit with the immediate.
“Regime change through street “revolutions†served its purpose once. But to have it virtually “institutionalised†as the preferred method everytime we are unhappy with a politician is the handywork of half-wits who are short on foresight and long on, well, vacuousness.” – benignO
What do you propose regular citizens like me to do instead? Do we just leave it up to the ombudsman to investigate the way we did with JOKJOK scandal? Do we leave the Congress to initiate an impeachment like the Garci tapes? Do I really have other avenues I can go to so I can complain that I don’t like getting shit on my head day in and day out? Can I go to the police and tell them I am being robbed? Do I leave it up to Gloria’s conscience to lift her stupid EO464? I want to know what can I really do.
Kasi this is not the first time. Mahaba nga ang pasensya ng Pinoy eh. Pero grabe na! As much as galit na ako sa mga reklamador at manggagamit at politiko, mas nakakagalit na binabastos na ako ng garapalan at wala akong magawa!
No matter what Mrs. Gaite gripe about what Lozada had said on her husband, she doesn’t deny that her husband gave Lozda 500k. Did she ever wonder where her husband got that amount and who is Lozada in her husband’s life that lozada enjoy so much privelege as borrowing that amount of money withoout condition.
This is becoming interesting. Did you get to hear the wiretap conversation of JDV111 and Lozada.
Heres the link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iEAVaXA8kBM
HELLO GLORIA SUPPORTERS!
Please visit http://lulisbrigade.blogspot.com/ and send your “daddy get well”, “mommy tell god I’m good too”, and “Gloria, my president right or wrong” emails.
Send money also, so they ease up on the taxes we paid.
Oops, my comment is awaiting moderation. Its the lulibrigade blog for the Gloria supporters – please let them know you’re here for them!
I just hope the prayer rallies can encourage more “insiders” to come out and tell the public what they know about the corruption in the government.
I think Jun Lozada is losing steam and we need more evidence from him or other star witnesses so that the opposition doesn’t lose momentum.
Mrs. Maribel R. Gaite, what do you want us to say? PAUTANG NAMAN!
“….we need more evidence from him or other star witnesses so that the opposition doesn’t lose momentum.” – Lester Cavestany
————
Hmmm…. why the opposition? I hate the opposition and is dismayed by Erap’s “escape” from prison. That is also an issue Gloria has to account for. Erap never wronged the Filipino (according to him) and refuses to even ask for an apology (the nerve!) and yet Gloria “pardoned” him.
Yes, the opposition may be drooling on this opportunity but we have to make sure they too are prosecuted and sent back to jail. So, deal or no deal? NO DEAL!
Mr Quezon, please allow my post. I think its relevant to the discussions here. Thanks
“You both are very articulate I give you that, but this is the real world – we have real people with real needs who need real results, some immediate (life threatening) and some long term. I really hope you help out a bit with the immediate.” — ramrod
But that’s not the niche I fill in the scheme of things. There are enough bozos here clamouring for IMMEDIATE results. These are the bozos that usually win the arguments in Pinoy society — the ones who get their immediately-gratifying street revolutions, their OA rallies, and their tear-jerking crying heroes.
There are enough ‘volunteers’ out there who dole out the proverbial fish. But there are not enough people who are able to grasp, much less teach the proverbial fishing technique.
Those who clamour for long-term results seem to be clearly in the minority. That’s because sustainable long-term solutions are devilishly difficult to implement, require a lot of discipline and foresight to see through (both virtues famously ABSENT in Pinoy society) and involve contemplation of things that ordinary schmoes consistently fail to grasp. That’s why people who manage at that level earn the big bucks, while those who think short-term are those you’d tend to find waddling around on the streets with clenched fists eternally beholden to the robed sector of our society.
No one’s saying this is the preferred method. How many times has GMA been “inoculated” from impeachment by faux impeachment complaints? How many times have investigations been impeded by E.O. 464? How many more scandals have to erupt before she loses legitimacy in your eyes, Benigs?
Benigs, we all want long-term results. But how are we going to get good governance in the long term if officials cannot be held accountable?
Did Gaite really say that the 500k was his? Because now Ermita’s saying that it came from a private source and not Gaite’s own.
Man, cant they practice their scripts before hitting the stage? Tsk
“What do you propose regular citizens like me to do instead? Do we just leave it up to the ombudsman to investigate the way we did with JOKJOK scandal? Do we leave the Congress to initiate an impeachment like the Garci tapes? Do I really have other avenues I can go to so I can complain that I don’t like getting shit on my head day in and day out? Can I go to the police and tell them I am being robbed? Do I leave it up to Gloria’s conscience to lift her stupid EO464? I want to know what can I really do.
Kasi this is not the first time. Mahaba nga ang pasensya ng Pinoy eh. Pero grabe na! As much as galit na ako sa mga reklamador at manggagamit at politiko, mas nakakagalit na binabastos na ako ng garapalan at wala akong magawa!” — Zel
This statement of yours is interesting: “Do we leave the Congress to initiate an impeachment like the Garci tapes?”. The fact that you ask this question goes to the heart of the reason why Pinoys suck at democracy.
Our job as citizens is to vote REPRESENTATIVES into Congress. The people who then win a seat in Congress are then responsible for REPRESENTING the voters.
So to answer your question, YES. Congress should be left to initiate an impeachment.
Where they fail in this representation, it becomes the duty of citizens to employ the proper channels to engage their respective representatives to “encourage” them to do the right thing. One of these channels is the next Congressional election. But there are also channels available IN BETWEEN Congressional elections. Pinoys just need to use their brains to understand these simple principles rather than delegat their thinking to the cretins who are dishing out all these “revolutionary” slogans today.
The rest of the day, and the rest of the 365 days in a year, our job is to focus on our job and raise our kids right. I don’t think Pinoys can get even THAT responsibility right.
kabayan, i’ve posted my ideas on this a couple of comments back. it’s easy really.
line up all present politicians supporting GMA admin. (appointed officials a must!). shoot them. list all opposition politicians, blacklist them. go look for leaders in the private and NGO sector.
then start the audit of every govt employee and jail those found to have assets and liabilities beyond their pay. jail the small fries and kill the big ones.
“Our job as citizens is to vote REPRESENTATIVES into Congress. The people who then win a seat in Congress are then responsible for REPRESENTING the voters.” – benignO
So if the CONGRESSMEN are our direct link to Gloria, we need to PEOPLE POWER this s*** of b****es instead of PEOPLE POWERING Gloria to boot her out of office.
If the Congressman in our district fails to listen to us NOW! Then let us remove them from office NOW!
i wish ordinary voters can directly remove their congressmen via a vote of none confidence. thatll scare them.
Most of these congressmen have guns (!). Every election time, there is a great deal of violence, and what is striking in the last election is the number of incumbent candidates killed (more than 40 yata). In my opinion, provincial congressmen have it the roughest when it comes to getting elected, because local provincial politics requires a lot of guns, goons and gold.
All EDSA’s should be criticized. Well-functioning democracies do not need EDSA’s — to “institutionalize EDSA’s” is, by design, to admit to a people’s inability to design for a healthy democracy. EDSA’s are counter-intuitive to how to design for a democracy. EDSA’s are “tapal” to a problema as opposed to solving the problema.
EDSA’s result in a suspension of an existing constitution, which is, by itself, an indication of an inherent flaw of EDSA’s.
If a people just can not believe that they do not have the ability to vet the candidates welll enough and that the officials they put in power have to be removed from their office within two years, then structure the Constitution so that elections are held every two years.
I hear more people saying the Constitution needs some change…
“All EDSA’s should be criticized. Well-functioning democracies do not need EDSA’s” – UP n student
Under the condition you gave, yes then all EDSA’s must be criticized. But remember 1986 EDSA didn’t happen in a democracy. Yes, in paper the Philippines was a republic then, but in form it was very far from that. So the judgment of the merits of 1986 EDSA must be done under totally different parameters. I will always be PROUD of EDSA and the ideals it espoused. I will NOT allow anything to tarnish that moment when I was truly proud of the FILIPINO!
“…the officials they put in power have to be removed from their office within two years, then structure the Constitution so that elections are held every two years.” – UP n student
Marcos was in power for 20.
Things are always easier to analyze in a perfect world where all factors remain constant.
benigno,
So I’ll just call my friends in Rotary, Jaycees, etc. and tell them they’re short term bozos thats why they don’t earn big bucks. And in the World Vision dinner tonight I’ll announce that its a waste of time because we need long term solutions and that the children who cannot go to school without help can wait. Not!
People who earn big bucks? Are you even one of them? I’m a regular at the EDSA Shang, I meet the people with big bucks really, even at Wack Wack, but not one of them can dish out the bullshit that you do – you’re in a different level.
Excuses, excuses. tsk tsk tsk.
Have you even met a real hero? One who picked up a victim of a crossfire in the middle of that crossfire and carried her to the nearest public official’s house for help only to be turned away because the public official did not want to get involved? You and your kind never will I guess, sad to say, the world needs less of COWARDS like you.
ramrod, the Church is a big part of the problem! by the mere showing of favoritism between not just individuals but SENATE WITNESSES, they CORRUPT the process of finding the TRUTH. They say they have the gift of discernment…well you know…they are only human like the rest of us.
===============
okay, after reading Mrs. Gaite’s letter i say, “THAT’S IT…ENOUGH OF THIS NONSENSE!”
I was fooled by this Lozada character for a while there. Enough making excuses for the little inconsistencies. When you lie under oath, whether through ommission or an addled brain, the rest of your testimony is GARBAGE. I despise his nonchalant finger pointing and dropping of names. PROVE ALL YOUR ALLEGATIONS before you drop more names.
BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT. PRESUMPTION OF INNOCENCE. Let’s get to the TRUTH . DO you want the TRUTH? Can you handle it? Then you better be prepared to go through the JUDICIAL, LEGAL PROCESS because that is how our SOCIETY works. NO MORE SHORTCUTS.
Thank you, Mrs. Gaite. I hope you read this, and I hope you know: If no one believes you, I DO.
ramrod, it doesn’t take a lot of brains to make a lot of money…just look at Britney Spears…
geez, i can’t believe you are DROPPING places and organizations to validate yourself! this is the internet, who cares WHO YOU ARE, it’s what you have to share that matters…
up n,
care to provide a check list serving as parameters for a “well functioning democracy”? let’s begin with how “democratic” elections should be carried out, shall we? or how impeachment procedures should be processed?
edsa indeed is not indeed. that’s why edsa 2 was a political deformity bearing consequential deformities. let this outcome gobble up its cause. then we can start anew.
i meant a string of edsas is indeed not needed.
“I was fooled by this Lozada character for a while there. Enough making excuses for the little inconsistencies.” – Mita
———–
Just be careful that Mrs. Gaite is not fooling you now. I still think little inconsistencies (if there really are some) are far better than blindingly glaring ones.
Wow Benigno, now you make sense. We are on the same page on this.
Zel, right. The best way to resolve this bruhaha is through an impeachment. It’s fair, legal and constitutional. But how? As I wrote in the previous thread, we must let our representatives in Congress represent our will. That is their job. These bozos in Batasan always forget their primary job responsiblity. Since they have been bought by Malacanang and vested interests so many times, now we better show these clowns who are their their real bosses. That’s us — the citizens! The silent majority has always been against this regime since 2005 as surveys show, so the masses are with us in this fight. We are not stoking what has not been there before. We only need to mobilize.
We must channel peoople power properly this time around. And throw away our mob mentality, which has always been guided by our emotions, and going down deeper actually reveal that they have manipulated by vested interests to suit their agendas — and I am sorry to say, that includes the Catholic Church and other religious groups too, even the business groups and other groups that are sprouting everytime there is a crisis.
I believe the call is for us to put those pieces (of truth) together – Mrs. Gaite
———
Exactly, we can’t piece them all together if the government refuses to hand theirs over because of EO464.
BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT. PRESUMPTION OF INNOCENCE. Let’s get to the TRUTH . DO you want the TRUTH? Can you handle it? Then you better be prepared to go through the JUDICIAL, LEGAL PROCESS because that is how our SOCIETY works. NO MORE SHORTCUTS.-Mita
Remember EDSA II happened before the case of Erap was tried by the court. If we shall wait for the legal process or the court to prove allegation of corruption in the present gov’t, things will tarry and before good justice see its course, the dish has ran away with the spoon.
Zel…there you go…you never know, do you? it’s all perception, based on our own experiences, right?
Dante wrote that the “hottest place in Hell is reserved for those, who in time of crisis, remain neutral.â€Â
A Call to Bloggers, Forumsite and Website Administrators Out There,
You sick and tired of this corrupt and abusive administration and wish to express your intense displeasure? Another BLOGSWARM this Sunday or Monday (February 24 to 25), the day of the EDSA I celebration/protest will be in the offing.
Like in the first Blogswarm, put your favorite face of Gloria (edited or unedited) in you article, put a title Gloria Resign! or something of similar effect, and place an article regarding this Evil b****y administration.
Either hyperlink or post your website here in Manolo’s site so that we and the Filipino people would see your work and gather both their active and silent accolades.
See you in the Cyberprotest!
(Note: Those who are able are enjoined to be part of both the Cyberprotest and Realtime Protest on February 25; the more talents you have, the more is expected of you
)
alas ka dora, EXACTLY. and we still refuse to learn our lesson??
“it’s what you have to share that matters…” – mita
And your share is…pardon me, more bull shit.
Mita,
Pardon me but unlike you I have a face and make make sure I do in every interaction that I’m in, if you were here earlier you could seen it. A face to a name for me still spells CHARACTER.
Mita,
Its not what you share (share what? words?) just go to the library its full of them. Its what you actually DO. Shame on you! and you call yourself a Filipino? You are a disgrace to your race!
ramrod, bullshit or not, there it is…ain’t life grand?
btw, you are pardoned.
ohhh….ramrod…cool ka lang…nasaan na ang character mo!
For all those who still believe in the BULLSHIT of just sharing WORDS without action, you are a disgrace to the human race! Evolution is action not hiding in a safe dark corner somewhere – get out and be counted!
yan ang Pinoy, di pahuhuli…dapat may pangalang PINAGMAMALAKI at mukhang ka-akit-akit…
sabayan mo pa ng endorsement ng simbahan…tiyak pasok na yan kahit saan pang halalan.
may pera, may mukha, may mga kagalang-galang na kaibigan, well-connected ika nga,…may na-uuto!
like i said, enough already…we are doing EXACTLY what we accuse politicians of doing…
Mita,
Sorry. I didn’t mean it to get out that way. To tell you honestly I have brothers being detained arbitrarily to this day – real heroes and its getting to me each time.
Again, I’m sorry…
“The best way to resolve this bruhaha is through an impeachment. It’s fair, legal and constitutional.” – Madonna
I agree. But this time around people will have to bite and not only bark. We have until October to prepare. We have until October to PRESSURE our Congressman to do what we want them to do. We have to watch our representatives and the slightest hint of treachery will be punished by removal from their seats. We must institutionalize accountability. We have to reclaim our place in this democracy.
Don’t get me wrong, the search for truth must continue. So investigations must go on. Let us use this as opportunity to learn. Let’s use these as tools to fire us up so we do not forget that crimes will be punished and criminals will rot in JAIL!
Mita:
All expenditures of government taxes come under legislative oversight. From what I can glean in news reports, only NEDA-ICC, a collegial body wholy under the executive branch of government, approved the NBN deal. From what I can see in the news, no legislative oversight was performed on the NBN deal — don’t you think Congress, whether it is the Senate or the lower house, is entitled to ask questions regarding the NBN deal?
While I agree that any criminal wrongdoing by the stakeholders of the NBN deal has to be addressed by the court, I think that there are basic policy issues that our legislature has to address with regards to the handling of foreign loans, grants and development assistance.
alas ka dora, EXACTLY. and we still refuse to learn our lesson??_Mita
I’d like to be clear on this, are you trying to say that people power afterall was not effective because we have placed wrong people in gov’t through this method?
When the devil quoted the scripture to suit his needs, who was at fault the devil or the scripture? I nevr regret my participation in the last edsa although i could not completely convince myself to accept GMA as the beneficiary. It was my resolve to give GMA the benefit of the doubt considering her credentials. And I don’t mind joining street protests all my life if this is the only way we can bring down a gov’t that has lost moral ascnedancy to govern.
Mita: we are doing EXACTLY what we accuse politicians of doing…
Enriching themselves with our money?
“Zel…there you go…you never know, do you? it’s all perception, based on our own experiences, right?” – Mita
———–
Mita,
I agree, its all perception, our very own reality is dependent on how we perceive things.
But we must also be critical of what and who we doubt because if people are so OBSCENELY INCONSISTENT and CONSISTENTLY INCONSISTENT chances are they’re telling you lies!
“I hear more people saying the Constitution needs some change…”
Cha-Cha again, the whirlwind of a topic going to circle again, same arguments, pro and con, hohum.
Actually, Mita is makes a lot of sense.
Mita ist been a long long way. I remember you in PCJ blog years before. wala ka pa ring kupas!
JMCastro,
Entitled? Yes of course…but for the investigation to have results we can chew on, those found of wrongdoing should be brought to the courts – the only real arbiter of disputes. None of this grandstanding and dramatics, to gain the public’s sympathy and which only hurts the innocent.
I still have faith in the judicial branch…if only we can all be patient and rational while pushing for the wheels to grind faster…
ramrod,
I didn’t know that. I’m sorry too and I hope your family is reunited soon. If there’s anything you need, don’t hesitate to shout and I’ll come running, even if it’s only to add another voice to your cause.
I do not trust Noli, he lost his old fire after he resigned his job as the original “Kabayan”; and now a Vice-President who is practically an impotent “Yes-man.” The hidden kingmakers might maneuver him to position yet to insure that the current bureaucratic hacks and influence peddlers keep their jobs and continue on their corrupt practices.
In fact I’m really wary of both Noli and FVR. The power structure of the Oligarchic Syndicates must be broken, and they could be using Noli and FVR to preserve their hides and their Crime Syndicates.
But we must also be critical of what and who we doubt because if people are so OBSCENELY INCONSISTENT and CONSISTENTLY INCONSISTENT chances are they’re telling you lies!-Zel
Agree. As an example- Gaite admitted lending the money to Lozada. Kulang na nga lang pag sabihan nya si Lozada na walang utang na loob. “tinulungan ko na sya ito pang igaganti nya sa akin”, sumbat ni Gaite. Pero ngayon ang sabi ni Ermita that money did not come afterall from Gaite’s own pocket but from some unnamed private person. Kung hindi ka ba naman ginagawang gago ng mga ito.
Mita- how will you bring this case in court.
Pressuring congressmen in October is a fine idea (although that gives Malacanang around 8 months to keep them well-fed), but I’m not gonna sit on my ass in the meantime. If we can lop the head off the snake, so much the better. So…when’s the next mass action?
EDSA 1 – Marcos was hated, Marcos was ousted.
EDSA 2 – Erap was hated (by his enemies), Erap was ousted.
I guess, they’re successes by themselves. The long term results are different matters altogether. It can be debated forever whether it is the right way or not and just like the French revolution, they will have for and against it. We didn’t end up like France or Cambodia after both times, so we can try some more times (using people power) and hopefully we end up like France. Giving up after failing (long term effect) twice doesn’t look good, right? I say we try again.
rego,
now that I’m back home, I get frustrated a lot because there’s so much that needs to be done…parang I want to move back to the States but my family is here.
I try to help the people who need it most…but wow…it can get very complicated.
Zel,
Yup, I tried to stay neutral and weigh everything. I saw the initial press con of Lozada kasi eh…almost 3 am yun.
May inconsistencies na after that…like the kidnapping. Timawag nya kasing “misunderstanding” at humingi daw sya ng tulong kay Lito Atienza….so I dunno why nag-iba ang hihip ng hangin.
Then there was the Fely Arroyo incident….nag backtrack sya dun…total turnaround.
But this letter of Mrs. Gaite, I not only saw her pain as a wife (which I am) but as an active Catholic who believed and still believes. It makes you realize, there are too many groups, like the Church, trying to corrupt the whole process for what? For what they believe is the truth…
Like Mrs. Gaite said, no one has a monopoly of the truth, and that is so very true. so I hope we stop acting like we do…and hopefully we’ll resolve this and get to a better place for the country.
“Dante wrote that the “hottest place in Hell is reserved for those, who in time of crisis, remain neutral.‖The Equalizer
And in the war of the animals and the birds, the bat learned its lessons well permanently.
Jon Mariano..it wasn’t about HATE. if that’s what it is all about..lalong walang sasama jan..
ramrod,
“You both are very articulate I give you that…”
salamat for stating the obvious
“…but this is the real world – we have real people with real needs who need real results, some immediate (life threatening) and some long term. I really hope you help out a bit with the immediate.”
immediate? look at what EDSA 1 and 2 have begotten? this is not to say that they should not have taken place, but we all have this propensity to go for the immediate. pagkasipa sa nakaupo, okay na. Mali tayo dun.
yes, this is the real world. and the reality is the country has more pressing problems than gloria. i’d rather help in job creation. besides, any kick-gloria efforts will continue even without me, so dun na lang ako magfo-focus sa job creation na talagang makakatulong
saka napaka-super sobra to the max naman to say na life threatening na (maybe to Lozada and Neri but not to the rest of Pinoys) ang situwasyon. parang comment ni Bro. Eddie na impending na daw ang bloodshed! asus!
alas ka dora,
paano mo naman na-equate na IKAW ang ginagawang gago…EMOSYON na lang yan, hindi ka na makaka-isip ng derecho kung emosyon lang paiiralin mo.
Mita, paano naman ang inconsistencies ng government men? (e.g. Sino ang humingi ng police protection? At saan ba talaga galing ang perang 500k na ibinigay ni Gaite kay Jun Lozada?)
alas ka dora,
The Lesson was, NO MORE SHORTCUTS, nakakatipid lang mga politico at hindi na sila nangangampanya! there’s a price to pay for the shortcuts we made. For one, we are left with a system of government that cannot get off the ground and institutions cannot work in synch with one another cause just one whisper and one sutsot and we rush off to the streets…
We keep doing people power and the politicians, especially the opposition (whoever they may be) will get so used to it, tatamarin na silang gawin ang trabaho nila…TRABAHO at OBLIGASYON NILA sa BAYAN ang dapat nating sinisigaw.
just a thought.
People Power your local congressman.
critical mass, as is so often hope for these days, may not come on the streets of Imperial Manila.
but it may come when these bozos that we put in office are suddenly besieged in their home turf.
they were put there to represent the people, yeah?
so why the hell are you letting these guys get away with representing their own narrow interests?
remember these guys (your local congressman/woman) may still have a conscience. or is so drunk on power that they would do anything their constituents tell them.
a greater understanding of the nature of representative democracy is what i think called for. because it seems that the only way any real change can be had is if you work through the institutions we already have. so why not work through your representatives in Congress. tell them, in no uncertain terms, what the will of the people in their district is. whatever it is.
lozada ain’t the only one who can “play the system”.
“For all those who still believe in the BULLSHIT of just sharing WORDS without action, you are a disgrace to the human race! Evolution is action not hiding in a safe dark corner somewhere – get out and be counted!”
Psst… Don’t look now, but someone has just recently crowned himself judge and jury here.
Kawawa naman. Marami pa namang “friends” sa Rotary and Jaycees, tapos frequent tumambay pa sa Shang.
-
Padamihan nga ba ng “heroes” na kilala?
Pataasan na lang tayo ng ihi, at least that’s a more objective measure…
“Lets face it, there are two types of bloggers, one actually does something (act on his words), the other – well, just makes up words.” — ramrod
Lest you forget, legislators’ jobs are to put words together to make Laws. A different branch of the government implements the Law, and various agencies EXECUTE the law.
Not everyone can be doers, dude. At the same time not everyone can be wordsmiths.
Just like there are people whose role in this earth is to create wonderous feats of engineering while others’ roles are to wipe the arses of those engineers when they grow old.
Kanya-kanyang role yan at kanya-kanyang iskil.
Don’t presume to be the judge of what is the better role or the better skill.
Mita wrote:
“But this letter of Mrs. Gaite, I not only saw her pain as a wife (which I am)”
and Mita answers alas ka dora:
“EMOSYON na lang yan, hindi ka na makaka-isip ng derecho kung emosyon lang paiiralin mo”
hmmmm… is it me or are you being inconsistent?
Jon,
Bakit naman ako ang tinanong mo? Sabi ko nga, wala sa atin ang may monopoly ng truth…
pero tignan mo, lahat ng inakusahan ni Jun Lozada ang sabi nila nadala sila sa paiyak-iyak nya….AT ang sabi rin nilang lahat humingi sya ng tulong. Bakit ka naman iiyak-iyak sa bagong kakilala mo lang?
Iisa lang naman ang sinabing humingi ng TULONG, si Lozada. Sinabi din nya yon sa press con nya at 3 am…nakita ko kasi yon. If I didn’t see that, tahimik ako ngayon. Kung sabihin nya ngayon misunderstanding yon, okay lang ako. I can understand there were mixed signals….pero pag-inakusahan naman na yung mga hiningan mo ng tulong ng kidnapping…susmaria…ewan ko na lang.
Nagtrabaho din ako at alam ko ang mga shortcut para mapadali ang trabaho. Naranasan mo na ba yung walang request pero kinukulit ka na sa taas ng mga boss? Tapos pahahabulin mo ngayon yung papeles para hindi masabit department mo…
di talaga maganda ang shortcut, no?
i used to react to some commenters here with impulse,especially benigno.
Effective din pala ang magbasa at makinig na lang sa mga opinion nyo. I used to think that benigno is cocky dahil parang dali lahat para sa kanya..ano ba yong linya nya..it is simple,you know.
One (maybe not only one) statement made sense is that we are more on shortcuts and not the long term.
Now, as to CVj’s what if’s :What if the Huks ruled,or something to that effect,we might have been like China or Vietnam.I don’t know,but as far as i know the chinese have been here for more than five hundred years,how come we are not like them yet?
But his concerns about the elites or elitists,at first sounded weird ,but being exposed to those roundtables about the failure of the coups and the military’s role, I am beginning to get his drift.
Now, to Devils’ inciteful comments on revolution,for me whatever the solution is; as long as its sustainable, I am for it.
keep your comments coming.
tonio wrote:
“People Power your local congressman”
I am with you here. They ask for a new brand of people power then lets give them a new brand of people power. Instead of meeting at a single place, simultaneous people power must be held in our respective districts.
Imagine Nograles, the Arroyos et.al besieged by the overwhelming majority in their own turfs all at the same time! Wow! Now that is a statement!
Mita, tinanong kita dahil sabi mo nagbago ang tingin mo kay Jun Lozada dahil may mga inconsistencies. Eh mas marami pa ang inconsistencies ng government men, di ba? So kailangan mo rin maging consistent.
some people here keep on insisting that we play by the rule when gma and her minions doesn’t and break all the rules! haven’t we tried impeachment? like three times? did she and her cohorts in congress played by the rules? it’s a numbers games, they said. ngayon buong bayan ayaw na sa kanya dahil punong-puno na! we have the numbers why not use to get her out of her throne?!
debate na lang ng debate. talk is cheap! panahon para mag-aksyon! ano pa bang proweba ang kailngan natin? beyond reasonable doubt? tingnan nyo na lang ang kaso ni ninoy, hanggang ngayon wala pa ring matukoy mastermind. pero may duda ba kayo kung sino ang talaga ang mastermind? ang hirap sa mga pilipino kasi puro na lang sarili natin and iniisip. kung sino ang malapit sa pwesto at nakikinabang ay nakikinakaw na rin at hindi na iniisip ang taong bayan na naghihirap. huwag na antayin pa si neri, wala ng pag-asang magsalita yon! nasa dark side na completely! alam na natin ang lahat at hindi lang naman nbn-zte deal ang corruption, meyron pang hello garci, north rail, south rail, macapagal highway at automated machine ng comelec! ano pa ba ang kulang para maniwala tayo?
huwag magpadala sa emosyon? sino ba ang hindi ma high blood di umalma sa mga kasakiman?
So the next time you see a senator on the streets waving a clenched fist or placard with a half-witted political slogan painted on it, ask him this question:
Why aren’t you doing the job we pay you to do?
Next time you elect halfwits who are veterans of recent coups to the Senate, ask them:
Are you able to put enough words together to come up with a Bill and debate it in the Senate?
The criteria are quite simple. It’s the expectations that Pinoys have on their politicians that are half-witted.
Zel, are you trying to point out inconsistencies in my comments? Like I said and I’ll repeat, perception, perception, perception…based on our own experiences.
Like I just said, unang labas pa lang ni Lozada nakita ko na. Pinagbigyan ko, for fairness’ sakes, marami nang dumaan…marami na ring nasabit. Hindi lang emosyon ang ginamit ko, nag-isip din ako. Isa pang taong sinabit, tama na.
at bakit parati na lng sa maynila ang sentro ng mundo? dapat buong bayan sa pilipinas ay makisali na rin!!! pareho lng naman na ginugutum ang mga mamamyan sa buong pilipinas. pero rin ng mga taga probinsya ang ninanakaw ni abalos at FG. at taga probinsya din naman ang mga kasabwat ni gma sa paglilinlang sa taong bayan. kayo tayong lahat ay dapat magalit ang sabay-sabay sumigaw at ipakita ang galit natin sa kanila! tingnan natin kung paano mag react ang mga tangang sundalo at general kung ang buong pilipinas na ang umalma ng sabay sabay.
Mita, you are nit picking on my emotion when you need to train your gun on the meat of the discussion about the inconsistencies of government officials. How would you explain where Gaite got the 500K? isa lang yan. ang sabi mo hindi ako makakapag isip kung emosyon lang ang paiiralin ko. I must say where is your brain on the matter? You have not oferred any answer to the simple example of inconsistency above. Besides, Mrs. Gaite’s pain as a wife over her husband’s involment in the present scandal is also emotion, masasabi mo ba na hindi nakapag-isip ng mabuti si Mrs. Gaite dahil emosyon ang pinairal nya.
i just want to see the look on these congressman’s faces when they start receiving text messages saying that their constituency office and their homes in the province are being picketed by the people who voted them in.
maybe then, they’d listen.
and maybe then, they’d start doing the job they we’re voted into Congress for. representing us.
and maybe now, we’d see what stuff the Filipino people are really made of. are we united, as so many people on manolo’s blog say we are? then let the people’s voices be heard, district by district.
I won’t formulate an answer Alas Ka Dora, nor do YOU need to….it’s not up to you…or me. We don’t have the answer because we were not there. Do you really think I’m trying to RESOLVE this whole mess just between us or even here? What good will it do?
Kung emosyon lang ginamit ni Mrs. Gaite nagpa press con na rin sya at nag-iiyak na din sa taumbayan. Ano ginawa nya? sumulat ng mahabang sulat sa mga pari ng La Salle kung saan kunektado din sya….that process of writing alone makes it a thinking, rational thing.
You yourself made it personal when you said ginagago ka. Sa akin ba nanggaling yon?
And I didn’t nitpick on you…I pointed it out.
ahaha. nice one karl.
sustainable revolution. nice.
shortcut is good when it will get you faster and better to where you need to go. when driving it is wise to take a more effecient route than the circuitous one.
Call people power or its variant a short cut as you may but if this is the most effecient way by which we can get rid of what is plaguing us at the moment, i dont mind taking this route.
Mita:
We are talking about budgetary questions already with regards to the NBN project, not a question about putting people in jail. Achieving budgetary transparency in government is a policy and governance issue, which is not a judicial but a political issue.
I do not agree that only legal truth is the only truth — what about the political truths which have to be resolved?
“Call people power or its variant a short cut as you may but if this is the most effecient way by which we can get rid of what is plaguing us at the moment, i dont mind taking this route.”
Jeez. How does one argue with a character who has such an inconsistent thinking framework as this?
Note the phrase ‘at the moment’. So what happens after this “moment” is gone? Everytime an Edsa “revolution” MOMENT passes, the addiction to this moronic activity increases. And as more moronic activities are undertaken at the drop of the hat, Pinoys IQ levels drop even further.
Tuluyan na nga talagang magiging moron ang Pinoy.
hmmm. last i heard, those working for the ouster of Erap are in government now, wallowing in corruption. those who were neutral then were, just that, neutral.
Mita,
I am trying to understand the inconsistencies in your statement. I would like to understand where you are coming from. You said you have to use facts and not emotions when you think. You considered yourself neutral until the letter of Mrs. Gaite. After the letter you made up your mind because as a wife you felt her pain, you said..
“Isa pang taong sinabit, tama na.”
Then you said nobody has the monopoly of the truth, but also said and I quote:
“Thank you, Mrs. Gaite. I hope you read this, and I hope you know: If no one believes you, I DO.”
I just don’t get it. Everybody has the right to defend themselves. Mr. Gaite can speak his truth, because truth is truth regardless of the forum. The problem in this scenario is that, government officials need LEGAL forums to speak their truth.
One cannot help but wonder.
I’m with Zel in this argument.
Mita pointed out Lozada’s inconsistencies, can she also point out the facts she saw from Jun Lozada?
Achieving budgetary transparency in government is a policy and governance issue, which is not a judicial but a political issue. — JMCastro
Tumpak! That’s why the NBN must be settled in the court of public opinion and the constitutionally mandated court for that is an impeachment court.
Sometimes it takes more than prayers to achieve discernment, and perhaps the revolution is not going to happen with the Filipino People, but with the clergy.
Thanks again for the link Sir Manolo ^_^
Tonio,
How do you think we can get this idea off the blogsphere and into the real world? I’m really excited to help organize our community to get the predominant sentiments on this issue and dictate this to our congressman with a force they never thought simple folks like us are capable of delivering.
you missed the point again, Mita. it is our responsibility to sustain our vigilance in order to keep gov’t officials on their toes and inculcate in their minds that shuld they do foolsh thing they would be made answerable to the people. Ang problema when Manny Gaite’s name was mentioned by Lozada as the generous man who provided the 500K, Mr. Gaite admitted it came from his own pocket. Now Ermita is saying it was provided by a private individual whose name they cannot disclose or would not disclose. Anong tawag mo dito hindi ba ka gaguhan o ginagawa nila tayong gago kasi hindi nila maipaliwanag ang katotohonan tungkol sa 500k. Between Lozada and these men who is more credible?
Tonio wrote:
” maybe then, they’d listen.
may be then, they’d start doing the job they we’re voted into Congress for, representing us.”
———————-
And maybe then we can be truly deserving of our democracy!
Mita:
“Zel…there you go…you never know, do you? it’s all perception, based on our own experiences, right?
“But this letter of Mrs. Gaite, I not only saw her pain as a wife (which I am)….”
Sometimes our perception is also based on sympathy.
Experiences and sympathies, both basic stoker of emotions, are good bases for perception, but the other senses ought to be utilize as well.
“Next time you elect halfwits who are veterans of recent coups to the Senate, ask them:
Are you able to put enough words together to come up with a Bill and debate it in the Senate?” – benign0
**********************************
SBN-2088: Rechargeable Battery Law
Filed on February 18, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2087: Highway Safety Program of 2008
Filed on February 18, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2086: 2008 Emergency Management Agency Act
Filed on February 18, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2085: Philippine Halal Act of 2008
Filed on February 18, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2084: Transfer in the Philippines of Science and Technology by Overseas Filipino Professionals
Filed on February 18, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2059: Pilotage Service Act of 2008
Filed on February 11, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2058: Post-Harvest Facilities Support Act of 2008
Filed on February 11, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2057: Pernicious Practice of Resigning From Elective Positions to Accept Appointive Positions
Filed on February 11, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2039: Philippine Youth Corps Program of 2008
Filed on January 30, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2038: Coffee Research, Development and Extension Center (Cordec)
Filed on January 30, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2037: Young Farmers Program Act of 2008
Filed on January 30, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-2000: Fire Protection Modernization Act of 2008
Filed on January 14, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-1999: Witness Protection, Security and Benefit Act
Filed on January 14, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-1998: Public School Democratization Law of 2008
Filed on January 14, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-1997: Checkpoints
An Act Regulating the Installation and Maintenance of Checkpoints Filed on January 14, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
SBN-1996: Senior Citizen Card
An Act Imposing Stiffer Penalties on Pharmacies and Drug Stores Which Refuse to Honor Senior Citizen Card Issued by the Government Filed on January 14, 2008 by Trillanes IV, Antonio “Sonny” F.
There are many more but the point has been proven.
hmmm. last i heard, those working for the ouster of Erap are in government now, wallowing in corruption. those who were neutral then were, just that, neutral. — Anthony Scalla
Hey, that is so not true. You mean to say that many people who worked for the ouster of Estrada, and that includes me, full disclosure, are now wallowing in corruption? No sir, no, that is not true.
Neutral parties — now and then — I don’t have a have data on that.
But how about the majority of the people who voted for Estrada who were against Edsa Dos, but have consistenly been against the GMA regime since 2005.
Facts, please.
nakupo! mabuti sana if this ‘short cut’ does not produce collateral damage! one lasting ‘collateral damage’ is the continued belief that ‘people power’ is available all the time
this ‘people power on demand’ does not do the country any good! that medicine is worse than the disease called gloria!
if only to diffuse, once and for all, this ‘people power on demand’ im willing to let gloria sit until 2010 (besides shes entitled to it), but without prejudice to bringing her to justice after her term ends